skills/proffesor-for-testing__agentic-qe

Fork 0

mirror of https://github.com/proffesor-for-testing/agentic-qe.git synced 2026-09-19 08:45:47 +08:00

Files

T

Profa 7f6ba0b659 unified implementation plan

2025-11-19 08:21:52 +00:00

42 KiB

Raw Permalink Blame History

Unified GOAP Implementation Plan: AQE Platform Enhancement

Comprehensive Multi-Path Implementation for Agent Observability, Visualization, and Constitution-Based Quality Evaluation

Version: 1.0.0 Created: 2025-11-19 Status: Implementation Plan Total Effort: ~160 hours (8-10 weeks) Total Actions: 50 (merged from 3 specifications)

Executive Summary

This unified implementation plan merges three GOAP specifications into a cohesive, phased approach for enhancing the Agentic QE Fleet platform. The plan delivers:

Agent Observability & Telemetry - OpenTelemetry-based distributed tracing with stakeholder dashboards
Explainable Visualization System - Interactive mind maps for agent decision trees
Constitution-Based Quality Evaluation - Multi-agent voting panels with explainable verdicts

Key Outcomes

100% trace coverage across all 18+ QE agents
Real-time visualization of agent decisions with <100ms render time
85%+ agent agreement rate on quality verdicts
Full CI/CD integration with quality gates
Autonomous feedback loops with OODA cycle adaptation

Timeline Overview

Phase	Duration	Focus	Key Deliverables
Phase 1	Weeks 1-2	Foundation & Infrastructure	Telemetry bootstrap, event persistence, constitution schema
Phase 2	Weeks 3-4	Core Instrumentation & Evaluation	Agent tracing, clause evaluators, voting protocol
Phase 3	Weeks 5-6	Dashboards & Visualization	Grafana dashboards, mind map UI, real-time streaming
Phase 4	Weeks 7-8	Integration & Orchestration	CI/CD, CLI, feedback loops, MCP tools
Phase 5	Weeks 9-10	Production Readiness	Calibration, optimization, documentation

Total Effort Breakdown

Path	Original Estimate	Merged Estimate	Notes
Path 3: Observability	70 hours	55 hours	Shared infrastructure with Path 1
Path 1: Visualization	8 weeks (160h)	45 hours	Reuses telemetry data layer
Path 2: Constitution	8 weeks (160h)	60 hours	Standalone, but uses shared metrics
Total	~390 hours	~160 hours	59% reduction through integration

Technology Stack (Open Source Only)

Core Infrastructure

Component	Technology	License	Version	Purpose
Telemetry	OpenTelemetry	Apache-2.0	1.x	Distributed tracing and metrics
Metrics Store	Prometheus	Apache-2.0	2.x	Time-series metrics
Trace Backend	Jaeger	Apache-2.0	1.x	Distributed trace visualization
Dashboards	Grafana	AGPL-3.0	10.x	Visualization and alerting
LLM Observability	Langfuse	MIT	2.x	LLM-specific traces and costs

Frontend Visualization

Component	Technology	License	Version	Purpose
UI Framework	React	MIT	18.x	Component framework
Graph Visualization	Cytoscape.js	MIT	3.x	Interactive graphs
Charts	Recharts	MIT	2.x	Quality metrics charts
Data Visualization	D3.js	ISC	7.x	Core visualization
Styling	Tailwind CSS	MIT	3.x	Utility-first CSS
Build Tool	Vite	MIT	5.x	Fast bundling

Backend & Runtime

Component	Technology	License	Version	Purpose
Runtime	Node.js	MIT	18+	JavaScript runtime
Language	TypeScript	Apache-2.0	5.x	Type-safe development
Database	SQLite	Public Domain	3.x	Event and evaluation storage
WebSocket	ws	MIT	8.x	Real-time streaming
Schema Validation	Ajv	MIT	8.x	JSON Schema validation
AST Parsing	@babel/parser	MIT	7.x	Code analysis

NOT Used (Commercial/Proprietary)

DataDog (Commercial)
NewRelic (Commercial)
Dynatrace (Commercial)
Any tool without MIT/Apache-2.0/ISC license

Phase 1: Foundation & Infrastructure (Weeks 1-2)

Objectives

Establish telemetry infrastructure that all three paths depend on
Create data persistence layer for events, traces, and evaluations
Define schemas for constitutions and visualization data

Actions (13 actions, ~28 hours)

1.1 Telemetry Foundation (Path 3)

ID	Action	Effort	Dependencies
A1	Install OTEL SDK Dependencies	30min	None
A2	Create Telemetry Bootstrap Module	4h	A1
A3	Define Comprehensive Metrics Schema	2h	None
A7	Deploy OTEL Collector	3h	A2

1.2 Data Persistence Layer (Path 1)

ID	Action	Effort	Dependencies
V1	Event History Persistence	3h	A2
V2	Reasoning Chain Capture	5h	V1
V3	Quality Metrics Aggregation	4h	V2

1.3 Constitution Schema (Path 2)

ID	Action	Effort	Dependencies
C1	Define Constitution JSON Schema	3h	None
C2	Create Base Constitutions	6h	C1
C3	Implement Constitution Loader	3h	C1

Claude-Flow Swarm Configuration

// Phase 1: Foundation Swarm
{
  topology: "hierarchical",
  maxAgents: 6,
  strategy: "specialized",
  agents: [
    { type: "architect", name: "telemetry-architect", capabilities: ["otel", "metrics", "tracing"] },
    { type: "coder", name: "bootstrap-dev", capabilities: ["typescript", "node"] },
    { type: "coder", name: "schema-dev", capabilities: ["json-schema", "validation"] },
    { type: "analyst", name: "metrics-analyst", capabilities: ["prometheus", "grafana"] },
    { type: "tester", name: "foundation-tester", capabilities: ["jest", "integration"] },
    { type: "coordinator", name: "phase1-coord", capabilities: ["orchestration"] }
  ]
}

Agent Execution Pattern

// Single message with parallel agent execution
[Phase 1 Parallel Execution]:
  Task("telemetry-architect", "Design OTEL architecture with collector config, exporters, and metric schema. Store decisions in aqe/telemetry/architecture.")
  Task("bootstrap-dev", "Implement telemetry bootstrap module with tracer/meter providers. Follow OTEL semantic conventions.")
  Task("schema-dev", "Define constitution JSON schema with principles, clauses, and scoring rules. Create base constitutions for code/test/docs.")
  Task("metrics-analyst", "Design Prometheus metric types and labels. Define alert thresholds and aggregation rules.")
  Task("foundation-tester", "Create integration tests for telemetry initialization and schema validation.")

Memory Namespace (Phase 1)

aqe/
  phase1/
    telemetry/
      architecture/          # OTEL design decisions
      bootstrap/             # Initialization code location
      collector-config/      # Collector YAML
    data/
      event-history/         # Event persistence schema
      reasoning-chains/      # Chain data structures
      metrics-aggregation/   # Aggregation algorithms
    constitution/
      schemas/               # JSON Schema definitions
      base/                  # Default constitutions
      loader/                # Loader implementation

Validation Criteria

Checkpoint	Test	Expected Result
OTEL SDK Works	`npm run test:telemetry`	All telemetry tests pass
Collector Running	`curl http://localhost:4318/v1/traces`	200 OK
Events Persist	Query last 100 events	Events retrievable from SQLite
Schema Valid	`aqe constitution validate`	3 base constitutions validated

Deliverables

Files Created:

src/telemetry/bootstrap.ts
src/telemetry/metrics/schema.ts
configs/observability/otel-collector.yaml
src/visualization/core/EventHistoryStore.ts
src/visualization/core/ReasoningCapture.ts
src/schemas/constitution.schema.json
constitutions/code-quality-v1.json
constitutions/test-quality-v1.json
constitutions/doc-quality-v1.json

Phase 2: Core Instrumentation & Evaluation (Weeks 3-4)

Objectives

Instrument all 18 QE agents with tracing
Implement clause evaluation framework
Build multi-agent voting protocol

Actions (12 actions, ~36 hours)

2.1 Agent Instrumentation (Path 3)

ID	Action	Effort	Dependencies
A4	Instrument Agent Lifecycle	8h	A2, A3
A5	Implement Token Usage Tracking	4h	A2
A6	Create Distributed Trace Propagation	6h	A4

2.2 Clause Evaluation (Path 2)

ID	Action	Effort	Dependencies
C4	Create Clause Evaluator Framework	8h	C3
C5	Design Voting Protocol	4h	C4
C6	Implement Panel Assembly	4h	C5

2.3 Consensus & Voting (Path 2)

ID	Action	Effort	Dependencies
C7	Implement Consensus Algorithms	6h	C5
C8	Create Voting Orchestrator	4h	C6, C7

Claude-Flow Swarm Configuration

// Phase 2: Instrumentation Swarm
{
  topology: "mesh",
  maxAgents: 8,
  strategy: "adaptive",
  agents: [
    { type: "coder", name: "agent-instrumenter", capabilities: ["otel", "spans", "async"] },
    { type: "coder", name: "token-tracker", capabilities: ["llm", "cost-tracking"] },
    { type: "coder", name: "evaluator-dev", capabilities: ["ast", "regex", "semantic"] },
    { type: "architect", name: "voting-architect", capabilities: ["distributed", "consensus"] },
    { type: "coder", name: "consensus-dev", capabilities: ["algorithms", "statistics"] },
    { type: "coder", name: "orchestrator-dev", capabilities: ["async", "coordination"] },
    { type: "tester", name: "instrumentation-tester", capabilities: ["jest", "spans"] },
    { type: "reviewer", name: "phase2-reviewer", capabilities: ["code-review", "quality"] }
  ]
}

Agent Execution Pattern

[Phase 2 Parallel Execution]:
  Task("agent-instrumenter", "Add OTEL spans to all 18 agent lifecycle hooks: spawn, execute, complete, error. Include semantic attributes.")
  Task("token-tracker", "Implement token counting middleware for LLM calls. Track input/output tokens, calculate costs per agent.")
  Task("evaluator-dev", "Build clause evaluators: AST (babel), metric (cyclomatic), pattern (regex), semantic (LLM). Handle all check types.")
  Task("voting-architect", "Design message formats for voting protocol. Define quorum rules and tie-breaking strategies.")
  Task("consensus-dev", "Implement majority, weighted, and Bayesian consensus algorithms. Handle disputed clauses.")
  Task("orchestrator-dev", "Coordinate parallel agent voting with timeout handling and result aggregation.")

Memory Namespace (Phase 2)

aqe/
  phase2/
    instrumentation/
      agent-spans/           # Span definitions per agent type
      token-metrics/         # Token tracking config
      trace-context/         # Context propagation patterns
    evaluation/
      evaluators/            # Evaluator implementations
      clause-checks/         # Check type handlers
    voting/
      protocol/              # Message formats
      panel-config/          # Agent selection rules
      consensus/             # Algorithm implementations

Validation Criteria

Checkpoint	Test	Expected Result
Agents Traced	`aqe telemetry trace --agent qe-test-generator`	Spans returned with timing
Token Tracking	`aqe telemetry metrics tokens`	Per-agent token breakdown
Clause Evaluation	`aqe constitution evaluate --clause C001 test.ts`	Verdict with findings
Voting Works	`aqe constitution evaluate file.ts --min-agents 3`	3 agent votes aggregated

Deliverables

Files Created:

src/telemetry/instrumentation/agent.ts
src/telemetry/instrumentation/task.ts
src/telemetry/instrumentation/memory.ts
src/telemetry/metrics/collectors/cost.ts
src/constitution/evaluators/ast-evaluator.ts
src/constitution/evaluators/metric-evaluator.ts
src/constitution/evaluators/pattern-evaluator.ts
src/constitution/evaluators/semantic-evaluator.ts
src/voting/protocol.ts
src/voting/panel-assembly.ts
src/voting/consensus.ts
src/voting/orchestrator.ts

Phase 3: Dashboards & Visualization (Weeks 5-6)

Objectives

Build Grafana dashboards for all stakeholders
Create interactive visualization frontend
Implement real-time streaming

Actions (12 actions, ~32 hours)

3.1 Stakeholder Dashboards (Path 3)

ID	Action	Effort	Dependencies
A8	Build Executive Dashboard	4h	A7, A3
A9	Build Developer Dashboard	4h	A7
A10	Build QA Dashboard	4h	A7, A4

3.2 Visualization API (Path 1)

ID	Action	Effort	Dependencies
V4	Visualization Data Transformer	4h	V1, V2, V3
V5	Real-Time Streaming Endpoint	5h	V4
V6	REST API for Historical Data	3h	V4

3.3 Frontend Visualization (Path 1)

ID	Action	Effort	Dependencies
V7	Interactive Mind Map Component	8h	V5
V8	Quality Metrics Graph Panel	6h	V3, V7
V9	Lifecycle Timeline View	5h	V7, V8
V10	Drill-Down Detail Panel	4h	V9

Claude-Flow Swarm Configuration

// Phase 3: Visualization Swarm
{
  topology: "star",
  maxAgents: 7,
  strategy: "specialized",
  agents: [
    { type: "coordinator", name: "viz-coordinator", capabilities: ["orchestration", "frontend-backend"] },
    { type: "coder", name: "grafana-dev", capabilities: ["grafana", "promql", "dashboards"] },
    { type: "coder", name: "frontend-dev", capabilities: ["react", "typescript", "d3"] },
    { type: "coder", name: "api-dev", capabilities: ["rest", "websocket", "streaming"] },
    { type: "coder", name: "cytoscape-dev", capabilities: ["cytoscape", "graphs", "layout"] },
    { type: "designer", name: "ux-designer", capabilities: ["ux", "accessibility", "design"] },
    { type: "tester", name: "e2e-tester", capabilities: ["playwright", "cypress", "e2e"] }
  ]
}

Agent Execution Pattern

[Phase 3 Parallel Execution]:
  Task("grafana-dev", "Create 3 Grafana dashboards: Executive (quality trends, costs), Developer (trace explorer, logs), QA (test metrics, coverage). Export as JSON provisioning.")
  Task("api-dev", "Build WebSocket server for real-time streaming and REST endpoints for historical queries. Implement backpressure handling.")
  Task("frontend-dev", "Create React app with Vite. Set up Tailwind, routing, and state management. Build base component structure.")
  Task("cytoscape-dev", "Implement interactive mind map with Cytoscape.js. Add expand/collapse, zoom/pan, search/filter. Support 1000+ nodes.")
  Task("ux-designer", "Design dashboard layouts and visualization UX. Create mockups for mind map interactions and drill-down flows.")

Memory Namespace (Phase 3)

aqe/
  phase3/
    dashboards/
      executive/             # Executive dashboard config
      developer/             # Developer dashboard config
      qa-leader/             # QA dashboard config
    visualization/
      api/
        websocket/           # Streaming config
        rest/                # REST endpoints
      frontend/
        components/          # Component architecture
        state/               # State management
      mindmap/
        layout/              # Graph layout algorithms
        interactions/        # User interaction handlers

Validation Criteria

Checkpoint	Test	Expected Result
Dashboards Load	Lighthouse audit	<2s page load
WebSocket Streams	Connect test client	Receive live updates <500ms
Mind Map Renders	Render 100 nodes	<100ms render time
Drill-Down Works	Click node	Detail panel shows data

Deliverables

Files Created:

dashboards/grafana/executive.json
dashboards/grafana/developer.json
dashboards/grafana/qa-leader.json
src/visualization/api/WebSocketServer.ts
src/visualization/api/RestEndpoints.ts
frontend/src/components/MindMap/MindMap.tsx
frontend/src/components/MetricsPanel/RadarChart.tsx
frontend/src/components/Timeline/LifecycleTimeline.tsx
frontend/src/components/DetailPanel/DrillDownPanel.tsx

Phase 4: Integration & Orchestration (Weeks 7-8)

Objectives

Implement alerting and feedback loops
Create CI/CD integration
Build CLI and MCP tools
Connect all subsystems

Actions (15 actions, ~38 hours)

4.1 Alerting & Feedback (Path 3)

ID	Action	Effort	Dependencies
A11	Configure Alerting Rules	3h	A7
A12	Build Autonomous Feedback Loop	8h	A4, A11

4.2 Output Generation (Path 2)

ID	Action	Effort	Dependencies
C9	Implement Result Aggregator	4h	C7
C10	Create Human-Readable Reporter	4h	C9
C11	Create Structured JSON Reporter	2h	C9
C12	Create Agent Control Loop Reporter	4h	C9

4.3 Integration Points (All Paths)

ID	Action	Effort	Dependencies
C13	CI/CD Integration	4h	C11
A14	Create Telemetry CLI Commands	4h	A2
C14	Constitution CLI Commands	4h	C8, C10, C11
V11	Visualization MCP Tools	4h	V10
C16	Constitution MCP Tools	4h	C14
C15	Memory Integration	2h	C9

Claude-Flow Swarm Configuration

// Phase 4: Integration Swarm
{
  topology: "hierarchical",
  maxAgents: 10,
  strategy: "balanced",
  agents: [
    { type: "coordinator", name: "integration-coord", capabilities: ["orchestration", "integration"] },
    { type: "coder", name: "alerting-dev", capabilities: ["prometheus", "alertmanager"] },
    { type: "coder", name: "feedback-dev", capabilities: ["ooda", "control-loops", "adaptation"] },
    { type: "coder", name: "reporter-dev", capabilities: ["markdown", "json", "templates"] },
    { type: "coder", name: "cicd-dev", capabilities: ["github-actions", "yaml", "workflows"] },
    { type: "coder", name: "cli-dev", capabilities: ["oclif", "cli-design", "commander"] },
    { type: "coder", name: "mcp-dev", capabilities: ["mcp", "tool-registration"] },
    { type: "coder", name: "memory-dev", capabilities: ["sqlite", "memory-namespace"] },
    { type: "tester", name: "integration-tester", capabilities: ["jest", "e2e", "integration"] },
    { type: "documenter", name: "api-documenter", capabilities: ["openapi", "markdown"] }
  ]
}

Agent Execution Pattern

[Phase 4 Parallel Execution]:
  Task("alerting-dev", "Configure AlertManager rules for critical/warning/info. Set up Slack/PagerDuty routing. Define alert suppression.")
  Task("feedback-dev", "Implement OODA feedback loop: observe metrics, orient analysis, decide actions, act on agents. Add concurrency/model adjustments.")
  Task("reporter-dev", "Build 3 reporters: human (markdown with findings), JSON (schema-validated), agent (control loop output with nextSteps).")
  Task("cicd-dev", "Create GitHub Actions workflow for constitution quality gate. Post PR comments with results. Set exit codes.")
  Task("cli-dev", "Add CLI commands: aqe telemetry {status,metrics,trace}, aqe constitution {evaluate,panel,calibrate}, aqe visualize {start,export}.")
  Task("mcp-dev", "Register MCP tools: aqe_telemetry_status, aqe_constitution_evaluate, aqe_visualization_start, aqe_visualization_export.")

Memory Namespace (Phase 4)

aqe/
  phase4/
    alerting/
      rules/                 # Alert rule definitions
      routing/               # Notification routing
    feedback/
      loop-config/           # Feedback loop parameters
      adaptations/           # Adaptation history
    output/
      templates/             # Report templates
      reporters/             # Reporter implementations
    integration/
      cicd/                  # CI/CD workflow configs
      cli/                   # CLI command definitions
      mcp/                   # MCP tool registrations

Validation Criteria

Checkpoint	Test	Expected Result
Alerts Fire	`aqe telemetry test-alert --level critical`	Alert received in 30s
Feedback Loop	Trigger high error rate	Agent concurrency adjusted
CI/CD Works	`act pull_request`	Workflow passes
CLI Commands	`aqe --help`	All commands listed
MCP Tools	`aqe mcp list	grep aqe_`

Deliverables

Files Created:

configs/observability/alertmanager.yaml
src/telemetry/feedback/loop.ts
src/telemetry/feedback/adaptations.ts
src/output/human-reporter.ts
src/output/json-reporter.ts
src/output/agent-reporter.ts
.github/workflows/constitution-gate.yml
src/cli/commands/telemetry.ts
src/cli/commands/constitution.ts
src/cli/commands/visualize.ts
src/mcp/telemetry-tools.ts
src/mcp/constitution-tools.ts
src/mcp/visualization-tools.ts

Phase 5: Production Readiness (Weeks 9-10)

Objectives

Calibrate and optimize all systems
Complete documentation
Verify all success criteria
Prepare for production deployment

Actions (8 actions, ~26 hours)

5.1 Calibration & Testing (Path 2)

ID	Action	Effort	Dependencies
C17	Create Calibration Test Suite	4h	C8
C18	Implement Agreement Metrics	2h	C7
C19	Create Appeal Process	4h	C9, C15

5.2 Performance Optimization (Path 1)

ID	Action	Effort	Dependencies
V12	Export & Sharing	3h	V11
V13	Performance Optimization	5h	V12

5.3 Documentation (All Paths)

ID	Action	Effort	Dependencies
A15	Observability Documentation	4h	A8, A9, A11
C20	Constitution Documentation	4h	C14

Claude-Flow Swarm Configuration

// Phase 5: Production Readiness Swarm
{
  topology: "mesh",
  maxAgents: 6,
  strategy: "adaptive",
  agents: [
    { type: "tester", name: "calibration-tester", capabilities: ["calibration", "statistics"] },
    { type: "optimizer", name: "perf-optimizer", capabilities: ["performance", "profiling"] },
    { type: "documenter", name: "tech-writer", capabilities: ["technical-writing", "markdown"] },
    { type: "analyst", name: "metrics-analyst", capabilities: ["metrics", "dashboards"] },
    { type: "reviewer", name: "qa-reviewer", capabilities: ["quality", "acceptance"] },
    { type: "coordinator", name: "release-coord", capabilities: ["release", "validation"] }
  ]
}

Agent Execution Pattern

[Phase 5 Parallel Execution]:
  Task("calibration-tester", "Create test suite with known verdicts. Run calibration to verify 85%+ agreement. Document calibration process.")
  Task("perf-optimizer", "Optimize mind map for 1000+ nodes: virtual scrolling, canvas rendering, web workers. Target <100ms render.")
  Task("tech-writer", "Write user guides, runbooks, and authoring guides. Document all CLI commands and API endpoints.")
  Task("metrics-analyst", "Set up monitoring dashboard for agreement rate, latency, and appeals. Configure drift detection alerts.")
  Task("qa-reviewer", "Run full acceptance test suite. Verify all success criteria. Document any gaps.")

Memory Namespace (Phase 5)

aqe/
  phase5/
    calibration/
      test-suite/            # Calibration test cases
      results/               # Calibration run results
      metrics/               # Agreement statistics
    optimization/
      performance/           # Performance benchmarks
      exports/               # Export implementations
    documentation/
      user-guides/           # User documentation
      runbooks/              # Operational runbooks
      api-docs/              # API reference

Validation Criteria

Checkpoint	Test	Expected Result
Calibration Passes	`npm run test:calibration`	All verdicts match expected
Agreement Rate	`aqe constitution metrics --metric agreement`	>= 85%
Render Performance	Render 1000 nodes	<100ms
Docs Complete	`ls docs/guides/*.md	wc -l`
All Criteria Met	Run full acceptance suite	100% pass

Deliverables

Files Created:

tests/calibration/*.ts
src/metrics/agreement.ts
src/appeal/process.ts
src/visualization/export/svg.ts
src/visualization/export/png.ts
src/visualization/optimization/virtual-scroll.ts
docs/guides/TELEMETRY-USER-GUIDE.md
docs/guides/CONSTITUTION-AUTHORING.md
docs/guides/CONSTITUTION-EVALUATION.md
docs/guides/VISUALIZATION-USER-GUIDE.md
docs/runbooks/alert-response/

Dependency Graph

Visual Representation

PHASE 1: Foundation
==================
A1 (OTEL SDK) ─────────┬──> A2 (Bootstrap) ──┬──> A4 (Instrument) ──> A6 (Propagation)
                       │                     │
                       │                     ├──> A5 (Tokens)
                       │                     │
                       │                     ├──> A7 (Collector) ──┬──> A8 (Exec Dash)
                       │                     │                     ├──> A9 (Dev Dash)
                       │                     │                     ├──> A10 (QA Dash)
                       │                     │                     └──> A11 (Alerts) ──> A12 (Feedback)
                       │                     │
                       │                     └──> A14 (CLI)
                       │
A3 (Metrics Schema) ───┼──> A4, A8
                       │
V1 (Event History) ────┼──> V2 (Reasoning) ──> V3 (Metrics Agg) ──> V4 (Transform)
                       │                                              │
                       └──────────────────────────────────────────────┬──> V5 (WebSocket) ──> V7 (Mind Map)
                                                                      │                          │
                                                                      └──> V6 (REST)            V8 (Charts)
                                                                                                  │
                                                                                                V9 (Timeline)
                                                                                                  │
                                                                                                V10 (Drill)
                                                                                                  │
                                                                                                V11 (MCP)

PHASE 2: Constitution Path
==========================
C1 (Schema) ──┬──> C2 (Base Const)
              │
              └──> C3 (Loader) ──> C4 (Evaluators) ──> C5 (Protocol) ──┬──> C6 (Panel)
                                                                       │
                                                                       └──> C7 (Consensus) ──┬──> C8 (Orchestrator)
                                                                                             │
                                                                                             └──> C18 (Metrics)

C8 ──> C9 (Aggregator) ──┬──> C10 (Human Reporter)
                         │
                         ├──> C11 (JSON Reporter) ──> C13 (CI/CD)
                         │
                         ├──> C12 (Agent Reporter)
                         │
                         └──> C15 (Memory) ──> C19 (Appeal)

C8 + C10 + C11 ──> C14 (CLI) ──> C16 (MCP) ──> C20 (Docs)
C8 ──> C17 (Calibration)

Critical Path

The longest dependency chain determines the minimum timeline:

A1 -> A2 -> A4 -> A6 -> A11 -> A12 -> A15
       |
       +-> V1 -> V2 -> V3 -> V4 -> V5 -> V7 -> V8 -> V9 -> V10 -> V11 -> V13
       |
       +-> C3 -> C4 -> C5 -> C7 -> C8 -> C9 -> C10 -> C14 -> C16 -> C20

Critical path duration: ~8 weeks (with parallel execution within phases)

Parallelization Opportunities

Within each phase, multiple actions can execute in parallel:

Phase	Parallel Groups
1	(A1, A3, C1) -> (A2, V1, C2, C3) -> (A7, V2)
2	(A4, A5, C4) -> (A6, C5) -> (C6, C7) -> C8
3	(A8, A9, A10, V4) -> (V5, V6) -> (V7, V8) -> (V9) -> V10
4	(A11, C9) -> (A12, C10, C11, C12) -> (C13, A14, C14) -> (V11, C16)
5	(C17, C18, V12) -> (C19, V13) -> (A15, C20)

CLI Commands Reference

Telemetry Commands

# Status and configuration
aqe telemetry status                      # Show telemetry status
aqe telemetry config                      # Show/update configuration

# Metrics
aqe telemetry metrics [metric-name]       # Query metrics
aqe telemetry metrics tokens              # Show token usage
aqe telemetry metrics quality             # Show quality scores

# Traces
aqe telemetry trace [trace-id]            # View specific trace
aqe telemetry trace --agent <type>        # Recent traces by agent

# Alerts
aqe telemetry test-alert --level <level>  # Trigger test alert

# Export
aqe telemetry export --format <format>    # Export data

# Feedback
aqe telemetry feedback status             # Show feedback loop status

Constitution Commands

# Management
aqe constitution init                     # Initialize for project
aqe constitution validate [path]          # Validate constitution files
aqe constitution list                     # List loaded constitutions
aqe constitution show <id>                # Show constitution details

# Evaluation
aqe constitution evaluate <files>         # Evaluate against constitution
  --constitution <id>                     # Use specific constitution
  --output <format>                       # human | json | agent | github-actions
  --min-agents <n>                        # Minimum agents on panel
  --specializations <list>                # Required specializations
  --fail-fast                             # Stop on first critical

# Panel
aqe constitution panel                    # Show panel configuration
  --artifact-type <type>                  # code | test | doc
  --min-agents <n>                        # Minimum agents
  --max-agents <n>                        # Maximum agents

# Calibration
aqe constitution calibrate                # Run calibration tests
aqe constitution metrics                  # Show agreement metrics

# Appeal
aqe constitution appeal <eval-id>         # Start appeal
aqe constitution appeal-status <id>       # Check appeal status

Visualization Commands

# Server
aqe visualize start --port 3001           # Start visualization server
aqe visualize stop                        # Stop server

# Export
aqe visualize export --format svg         # Export as SVG
aqe visualize export --format png         # Export as PNG
aqe visualize export --format json        # Export data as JSON

# Trace
aqe visualize trace <task-id>             # Visualize specific task

Milestones & Success Criteria

Milestone Summary

ID	Name	Target	Key Metric
M1	Infrastructure Ready	Week 2	OTEL Collector running, schemas validated
M2	Core Instrumentation	Week 4	100% agent trace coverage
M3	Dashboards Live	Week 6	All 3 dashboards <2s load
M4	Integration Complete	Week 8	CI/CD, CLI, MCP all working
M5	Production Ready	Week 10	All success criteria met

Detailed Success Criteria

Observability (Path 3)

Criterion	Target	Test
Trace Coverage	100%	Every agent operation has spans
Metric Collection	All schema metrics	Prometheus query validation
Dashboard Load	<2s	Lighthouse audit
Alert Latency	<30s	Timestamp delta test
Feedback Activation	<5min	Adaptation time measurement
MTTR Improvement	50% reduction	Historical comparison

Visualization (Path 1)

Criterion	Target	Test
Decision Trace Time	<5s	User study: trace to root cause
Render Latency (100 nodes)	<100ms	Performance API
Render Latency (1000 nodes)	<500ms	Performance API
Real-time Lag	<500ms	Timestamp comparison
User Comprehension	>80%	User study
All 19 Agents	100%	Matrix test

Constitution (Path 2)

Criterion	Target	Test
Constitution Coverage	100% (code, tests, docs)	Schema validation
Agent Agreement	>=85%	Calibration test suite
Judgment Explainability	100%	All verdicts cite clauses
Response Time (File)	<5s	P95 latency
Response Time (PR)	<60s	P95 latency
CI/CD Integration	Fully automated	Workflow test
Structured Output	100% schema valid	JSON Schema validation

Go/No-Go Decision Points

Phase	Decision Point	Criteria
End Phase 1	Proceed to Phase 2?	Collector running, schemas valid, events persisting
End Phase 2	Proceed to Phase 3?	Agents traced, voting works, evaluators functional
End Phase 3	Proceed to Phase 4?	Dashboards load <2s, mind map renders <100ms
End Phase 4	Proceed to Phase 5?	CI/CD passes, CLI works, MCP tools registered
End Phase 5	Production release?	All success criteria met, docs complete

Risk Mitigation

Technical Risks

Risk	Probability	Impact	Mitigation
Metric cardinality explosion	Medium	High	Label review process, cardinality limits in Prometheus
Performance with large graphs	High	Medium	Virtual scrolling, canvas rendering, level-of-detail
Agent disagreement too high	Medium	High	Calibration suite, clause specificity tuning, voting weights
Semantic checks unreliable	High	Medium	Ensemble approach, deterministic fallbacks
Real-time sync issues	Medium	Medium	Sequence numbers, reconciliation protocol
Memory leaks in visualization	Medium	Medium	Strict cleanup, WeakMap usage, memory profiling

Organizational Risks

Risk	Probability	Impact	Mitigation
Teams reject automated judgments	High	High	Start with advisory mode, demonstrate value, allow overrides
Constitutions too strict/lenient	Medium	Medium	Progressive thresholds, team-specific tuning, appeals
Alert fatigue	Medium	High	Tuning, suppression rules, well-written runbooks
Dashboard complexity	Medium	Medium	Stakeholder-specific views, training materials

Timeline Risks

Risk	Probability	Impact	Mitigation
OTEL learning curve	Medium	Low	Documentation, examples, pair programming
Stakeholder alignment	Low	Medium	Early reviews, iterative design, feedback loops
Infrastructure delays	Low	Medium	Containerized deployment, local development mode
Scope creep	Medium	High	Strict phase gates, prioritized backlog

Resource Requirements

Development Team

Role	FTE	Skills
Backend Developer	1.5	TypeScript, Node.js, OTEL, distributed systems
Frontend Developer	1	React, D3.js/Cytoscape.js, TypeScript
DevOps/SRE	0.5	Prometheus, Grafana, AlertManager, Docker
QE/Test Engineer	0.5	Jest, Playwright, calibration testing
Technical Writer	0.25	Documentation, runbooks

Infrastructure

Component	Resources	Monthly Cost
OTEL Collector	1 CPU, 1GB RAM	$0 (self-hosted)
Prometheus	2 CPU, 4GB RAM, 100GB storage	$10-50
Grafana	1 CPU, 1GB RAM	$0 (OSS)
Jaeger	1 CPU, 2GB RAM, 50GB storage	$0 (self-hosted)
SQLite	File storage	$0
Total		$10-50/month

Appendix A: Action ID Mapping

Path 3 (Observability) Actions

Original ID	Unified ID	Name
A1_INSTALL_OTEL	A1	Install OTEL SDK Dependencies
A2_TELEMETRY_BOOTSTRAP	A2	Create Telemetry Bootstrap Module
A3_METRICS_SCHEMA	A3	Define Comprehensive Metrics Schema
A4_INSTRUMENT_AGENTS	A4	Instrument Agent Lifecycle
A5_TOKEN_TRACKING	A5	Implement Token Usage Tracking
A6_TRACE_PROPAGATION	A6	Create Distributed Trace Propagation
A7_OTEL_COLLECTOR	A7	Deploy OTEL Collector
A8_EXEC_DASHBOARD	A8	Build Executive Dashboard
A9_DEV_DASHBOARD	A9	Build Developer Dashboard
A10_QA_DASHBOARD	A10	Build QA Dashboard
A11_ALERT_RULES	A11	Configure Alerting Rules
A12_FEEDBACK_LOOP	A12	Build Autonomous Feedback Loop
A14_CLI_COMMANDS	A14	Create Telemetry CLI Commands
A15_DOCUMENTATION	A15	Write Observability Documentation

Path 1 (Visualization) Actions

Original ID	Unified ID	Name
event-history-persistence	V1	Event History Persistence
reasoning-chain-capture	V2	Reasoning Chain Capture
quality-metrics-aggregation	V3	Quality Metrics Aggregation
visualization-data-transformer	V4	Visualization Data Transformer
realtime-streaming-endpoint	V5	Real-Time Streaming Endpoint
rest-api-historical	V6	REST API for Historical Data
interactive-mindmap-component	V7	Interactive Mind Map Component
quality-metrics-graph	V8	Quality Metrics Graph Panel
lifecycle-timeline-view	V9	Lifecycle Timeline View
drilldown-detail-panel	V10	Drill-Down Detail Panel
mcp-tool-integration	V11	MCP Tool Integration
export-sharing	V12	Export & Sharing
performance-optimization	V13	Performance Optimization

Path 2 (Constitution) Actions

Original ID	Unified ID	Name
A001	C1	Define Constitution JSON Schema
A002	C2	Create Base Constitutions
A003	C3	Implement Constitution Loader
A004	C4	Create Clause Evaluator Framework
A005	C5	Design Voting Protocol
A006	C6	Implement Panel Assembly
A007	C7	Implement Consensus Algorithms
A008	C8	Create Voting Orchestrator
A009	C9	Implement Result Aggregator
A010	C10	Create Human-Readable Reporter
A011	C11	Create Structured JSON Reporter
A012	C12	Create Agent Control Loop Reporter
A013	C13	CI/CD Integration
A014	C14	Constitution CLI Commands
A015	C15	Memory Integration
A016	C16	Constitution MCP Tools
A017	C17	Create Calibration Test Suite
A018	C18	Implement Agreement Metrics
A019	C19	Create Appeal Process
A020	C20	Constitution Documentation

Appendix B: Memory Namespace Structure

aqe/
  telemetry/
    architecture/            # OTEL design decisions
    bootstrap/               # Initialization config
    collector-config/        # Collector YAML
    metrics-schema/          # Metric definitions

  tracing/
    context/                 # Trace context propagation
    agent-spans/             # Per-agent span configs

  visualization/
    event-history/           # Event persistence
    reasoning-chains/        # Chain data
    metrics-aggregation/     # Aggregated metrics
    api/
      websocket/             # Streaming config
      rest/                  # REST endpoints
    frontend/
      components/            # Component state

  constitution/
    schemas/                 # JSON Schema definitions
    active/                  # Loaded constitutions
    evaluators/              # Evaluator configs

  voting/
    protocol/                # Message formats
    panel-config/            # Agent selection
    consensus/               # Algorithm configs

  evaluations/
    {timestamp}/
      result.json
      votes/
        {agent-id}.json

  feedback/
    loop-config/             # Feedback parameters
    adaptations/             # Adaptation history

  integration/
    cicd/                    # CI/CD configs
    cli/                     # CLI definitions
    mcp/                     # MCP registrations

  calibration/
    test-suite/              # Test cases
    results/                 # Run results
    metrics/                 # Agreement stats

  appeals/
    {appeal-id}/
      original.json
      review.json
      verdict.json

Appendix C: Inter-Phase Dependencies

Shared Infrastructure

The following infrastructure is shared across all three paths:

Telemetry Bootstrap (A2) - Used by visualization for event capture
Metrics Schema (A3) - Used by dashboards and quality evaluation
OTEL Collector (A7) - Central data collection for all metrics
Event History (V1) - Used by both visualization and constitution auditing
Quality Metrics Aggregation (V3) - Used by dashboards and constitution scoring
Memory Integration (C15) - Shared memory namespace for all paths

Cross-Path Data Flows

Observability -> Visualization
  - Trace data feeds mind map
  - Metrics power charts
  - Alerts trigger visual updates

Observability -> Constitution
  - Token metrics inform cost-aware evaluation
  - Trace context links evaluations to operations

Visualization -> Constitution
  - Mind map can visualize evaluation results
  - Timeline shows evaluation events

Constitution -> Visualization
  - Evaluation results displayed in detail panel
  - Quality scores shown in metrics charts

Constitution -> Observability
  - Evaluation metrics feed dashboards
  - Agent performance tracked

End of Unified Implementation Plan

This plan provides a comprehensive roadmap for implementing all three GOAP paths in an integrated manner. Execute phases sequentially while maximizing parallel execution within each phase. Use Claude-Flow swarm orchestration for efficient agent coordination.

42 KiB Raw Permalink Blame History

Unified GOAP Implementation Plan: AQE Platform Enhancement

Comprehensive Multi-Path Implementation for Agent Observability, Visualization, and Constitution-Based Quality Evaluation

Executive Summary

Key Outcomes

Timeline Overview

Total Effort Breakdown

Technology Stack (Open Source Only)

Core Infrastructure

Frontend Visualization

Backend & Runtime

NOT Used (Commercial/Proprietary)

Phase 1: Foundation & Infrastructure (Weeks 1-2)

Objectives

Actions (13 actions, ~28 hours)

1.1 Telemetry Foundation (Path 3)

1.2 Data Persistence Layer (Path 1)

1.3 Constitution Schema (Path 2)

Claude-Flow Swarm Configuration

Agent Execution Pattern

Memory Namespace (Phase 1)

Validation Criteria

Deliverables

Phase 2: Core Instrumentation & Evaluation (Weeks 3-4)

Objectives

Actions (12 actions, ~36 hours)

2.1 Agent Instrumentation (Path 3)

2.2 Clause Evaluation (Path 2)

2.3 Consensus & Voting (Path 2)

Claude-Flow Swarm Configuration

Agent Execution Pattern

Memory Namespace (Phase 2)

Validation Criteria

Deliverables

Phase 3: Dashboards & Visualization (Weeks 5-6)

Objectives

Actions (12 actions, ~32 hours)

3.1 Stakeholder Dashboards (Path 3)

3.2 Visualization API (Path 1)

3.3 Frontend Visualization (Path 1)

Claude-Flow Swarm Configuration

Agent Execution Pattern

Memory Namespace (Phase 3)

Validation Criteria

Deliverables

Phase 4: Integration & Orchestration (Weeks 7-8)

Objectives

Actions (15 actions, ~38 hours)

4.1 Alerting & Feedback (Path 3)

4.2 Output Generation (Path 2)

4.3 Integration Points (All Paths)

Claude-Flow Swarm Configuration

Agent Execution Pattern

Memory Namespace (Phase 4)

Validation Criteria

Deliverables

Phase 5: Production Readiness (Weeks 9-10)

Objectives

Actions (8 actions, ~26 hours)

5.1 Calibration & Testing (Path 2)

5.2 Performance Optimization (Path 1)

5.3 Documentation (All Paths)

Claude-Flow Swarm Configuration

Agent Execution Pattern

Memory Namespace (Phase 5)

Validation Criteria

Deliverables

Dependency Graph

Visual Representation

Critical Path

Parallelization Opportunities

CLI Commands Reference

Telemetry Commands

Constitution Commands

Visualization Commands

Milestones & Success Criteria

Milestone Summary

Detailed Success Criteria

Observability (Path 3)

Visualization (Path 1)

42 KiB

Raw Permalink Blame History