Prioritize saved HWP forms for ordinary stock-company promoter incorporations, make required court-registry receipts and director identity certificates explicit, and remove the redundant markdown articles template so the skill stays HWP-first.
Constraint: 법원등기소 기준 체크리스트 must include fee receipts, director seal/signature certificates, and resident-record documents.
Rejected: Keeping a separate markdown articles template | duplicated the stored HWP articles workflow and encouraged non-HWP drafting.
Confidence: high
Scope-risk: narrow
Directive: Keep corporate-registration-consulting focused on stored HWP form copies and explicit issued-document checklists.
Tested: node --test --test-name-pattern 'corporate-registration-consulting' scripts/skill-docs.test.js; node --check scripts/skill-docs.test.js; ./scripts/validate-skills.sh; git diff --check
Not-tested: Full npm run ci was not run because this is a skill documentation/template refactor, not release or package automation.
Bundle official court incorporation forms plus public startup incorporation attachments, and make rhwp-filled HWP outputs the default drafting path for the corporate-registration skill. Replace the listed-company articles reference with a startup-suitable Ministry of Justice stock-company form and record source manifests for bundled binaries.
Constraint: user requires actual sourced HWP templates, not generated placeholder binaries.
Rejected: markdown-only drafting | it cannot produce submission-shaped Korean registry forms.
Rejected: listed-company standard articles as the default reference | it is mismatched for typical startup incorporation.
Confidence: high
Scope-risk: moderate
Directive: keep bundled HWP forms source-backed, sanitized, and edited only through copied working files.
Tested: node --test scripts/skill-docs.test.js; npm run lint; k-skill-rhwp info on bundled HWP files; kordoc conversion spot checks.
Not-tested: manual opening every HWP in Hancom Office and live registry submission.
Co-authored-by: OmX <omx@oh-my-codex.dev>
Keep the consulting skill focused on draft/checklist support while pointing users to current IROS and law.go.kr form sources for submission-ready artifacts.
Constraint: official registry forms can change outside the repository and must be re-downloaded at use time
Rejected: committing copied official HWP/HWPX/PDF forms | they would become stale and risk misleading users
Confidence: high
Scope-risk: narrow
Directive: do not treat Markdown templates as substitutes for official registry submission forms
Tested: npm test
Tighten the Korean corporate registration skill after round-3 review by keeping filled HWP examples outside the repository, turning the investigation-report conclusion into a user/expert-confirmed placeholder, and locking human-only final action prohibitions with regression coverage.
Constraint: Legal-document workflow must avoid collecting or committing filled PII artifacts
Constraint: Agent may prepare drafts and checklists only, not final legal/tax conclusions or filings
Rejected: Add out/ to .gitignore | safer to teach non-repo private output for sensitive generated forms
Confidence: high
Scope-risk: narrow
Tested: node --test --test-name-pattern='corporate-registration-consulting' scripts/skill-docs.test.js
Tested: npx --yes k-skill-rhwp create-blank <tmp>/blank.hwp && npx --yes k-skill-rhwp info <tmp>/blank.hwp
Tested: npm run ci
Round-two review showed that the new consulting skill still needed explicit stop gates for non-standard incorporation paths and tighter documentation regression locks. The follow-up keeps the user-facing flow beginner-friendly while routing materially different legal/tax structures to official or professional review before draft generation.
Constraint: Legal-document skill must remain reference-only and avoid implying filing, tax, or governance determinations for non-standard cases
Rejected: Keep broad regex alternations for human-only boundaries | they allowed prior safety requirements to regress while tests still passed
Confidence: high
Scope-risk: narrow
Directive: Do not collapse the separate safety-boundary assertions back into alternations without a stronger replacement
Tested: node --test --test-name-pattern='corporate-registration-consulting' scripts/skill-docs.test.js
Tested: npx --yes k-skill-rhwp create-blank <tmp>/blank.hwp && npx --yes k-skill-rhwp info <tmp>/blank.hwp
Tested: npm run ci
The review follow-up closes legal-document safety gaps before merge by locking the expected guidance in the docs regression test and updating the skill surfaces that users and agents rely on. The representative-director clause now avoids board-resolution wording for the common two-director/no-board case, registration-license tax points to the direct 지방세법 제28조 anchor, and PII plus human-only filing boundaries are repeated where filled document workflows can expose sensitive data.
Constraint: PR review requested TDD coverage for legal/tax safety wording and privacy guidance
Rejected: Keep a single generic disclaimer only | document templates also need local warnings where filled artifacts are produced
Confidence: high
Scope-risk: narrow
Directive: Do not remove the repeated privacy and human-only boundaries unless every user-facing generation surface keeps equivalent guidance
Tested: node --test --test-name-pattern='corporate-registration-consulting' scripts/skill-docs.test.js
Tested: npx --yes k-skill-rhwp create-blank <tmp>/blank.hwp && npx --yes k-skill-rhwp info <tmp>/blank.hwp
Tested: npm run ci
Add a reference-only corporate registration consulting skill for first-time Korean incorporation workflows. The skill keeps user decisions explicit, provides conservative articles/document templates, and routes HWP automation through existing rhwp/kordoc surfaces instead of introducing new machinery.
Constraint: Issue #168 requires legal-disclaimer wording, tax pitfall guidance, rhwp-based form support, TDD, and PR delivery to dev.
Rejected: Add a new package or external automation dependency | existing skill docs and rhwp tooling are enough for this documentation/template workflow.
Confidence: high
Scope-risk: narrow
Directive: Do not present generated registration documents as legal or tax advice; keep official-source verification and professional review caveats visible.
Tested: node --test --test-name-pattern='corporate-registration-consulting' scripts/skill-docs.test.js; npx --yes k-skill-rhwp create-blank/info smoke; npm run ci
Not-tested: Live court registry submission or live tax payment, intentionally outside reference-skill scope
Jeffrey (Dongkyu) Kim