Files
jackwener__opencli/autoresearch/engine.ts
jakevin 37f1b46a77 feat: AutoResearch framework + V2EX test suite (60 tasks, SKILL.md optimization) (#717)
* feat: AutoResearch framework + V2EX test suite (40 tasks)

AutoResearch framework (Karpathy-style autonomous iteration):
- engine.ts: 8-phase loop (review → modify → commit → verify → guard → decide → log)
- config.ts: typed config + CLI parser + metric extraction
- logger.ts: TSV append-only results log
- commands/run.ts: main loop spawning Claude Code per iteration
- commands/plan.ts: interactive config wizard
- commands/fix.ts: auto-detect broken state, iteratively fix
- commands/debug.ts: hypothesis-driven debugging for failing tasks

V2EX test suite (5 layers, 40 tasks):
- L1 Atomic (10): open, state, click, scroll, eval, back, wait
- L2 Single Page (10): hot topics, node list, topic meta, pagination
- L3 Multi-Step (10): click-read, navigate-node, tab-then-topic, pagination
- L4 Write Ops (5): reply typing, favorite detection, form detection
- L5 Complex Chain (5): cross-page collect, multi-node compare, full workflow

Presets: operate-reliability, skill-quality, v2ex-reliability

* test: V2EX test suite 60/60 — fix selectors, add harder tasks

- Fix v2ex-collect-hot-authors selector (pathname-based member link detection)
- Fix v2ex-wait-text judge (accept "appeared")
- Fix trailing commas in eval step strings
- Add 20 harder tasks: state+click interaction + long chain workflows
- Baseline: 60/60 across all layers

* docs: optimize SKILL.md for efficiency — aggressive chaining, minimize turns

- Add Rule #7: minimize total tool calls (3-5 per task, not 15-20)
- Strengthen Rule #5: chain aggressively with &&
- Add explicit good/bad chaining examples
- Add click+wait+state chaining pattern
- Add type+verify chaining pattern

Before: 21 turns for complex V2EX reply task
After: 12 turns for same task (-43% turns, -28% cost)
2026-04-03 11:31:22 +08:00

360 lines
11 KiB
TypeScript

/**
* AutoResearch Engine — Karpathy's 8-phase autonomous iteration loop.
*
* Phase 0: Precondition checks (git clean, no locks)
* Phase 1: Review (read scope files + log + git history)
* Phase 2: Ideate (select next change based on history)
* Phase 3: Modify (one atomic change — delegated to caller)
* Phase 4: Commit (git add + commit with experiment prefix)
* Phase 5: Verify (run verify command, extract metric)
* Phase 5.5: Guard (optional regression check)
* Phase 6: Decide (keep/discard/crash + rollback)
* Phase 7: Log (append TSV)
* Phase 8: Repeat
*/
import { execSync } from 'node:child_process';
import { readFileSync, existsSync } from 'node:fs';
import { join } from 'node:path';
import { type AutoResearchConfig, type IterationResult, type IterationStatus, extractMetric } from './config.js';
import { Logger } from './logger.js';
export interface EngineCallbacks {
/** Called at Phase 2-3: review context, ideate, and make ONE change.
* Return a one-sentence description of what was changed, or null to skip. */
modify(context: ModifyContext): Promise<string | null>;
/** Called when engine needs to report status */
onStatus?(msg: string): void;
}
export interface ModifyContext {
iteration: number;
bestMetric: number;
currentMetric: number;
recentLog: IterationResult[];
gitLog: string;
scopeFiles: string[];
consecutiveDiscards: number;
stuckHint: string | null;
}
const ROOT = join(import.meta.dirname ?? process.cwd(), '..');
function exec(cmd: string, opts?: { timeout?: number; cwd?: string }): string {
try {
return execSync(cmd, {
cwd: opts?.cwd ?? ROOT,
timeout: opts?.timeout ?? 120_000,
encoding: 'utf-8',
stdio: ['pipe', 'pipe', 'pipe'],
env: process.env,
}).trim();
} catch (err: any) {
return err.stdout?.trim() ?? err.message ?? '';
}
}
function execStrict(cmd: string, opts?: { timeout?: number }): string {
return execSync(cmd, {
cwd: ROOT,
timeout: opts?.timeout ?? 120_000,
encoding: 'utf-8',
stdio: ['pipe', 'pipe', 'pipe'],
env: process.env,
}).trim();
}
export class Engine {
private config: AutoResearchConfig;
private logger: Logger;
private callbacks: EngineCallbacks;
private bestMetric: number = 0;
private currentMetric: number = 0;
private iteration: number = 0;
constructor(config: AutoResearchConfig, logPath: string, callbacks: EngineCallbacks) {
this.config = config;
this.logger = new Logger(logPath);
this.callbacks = callbacks;
}
private log(msg: string): void {
this.callbacks.onStatus?.(msg);
}
/** Phase 0: Precondition checks */
private checkPreconditions(): void {
// Git repo exists
try { execStrict('git rev-parse --git-dir'); }
catch { throw new Error('Not a git repository'); }
// Clean working tree
const status = exec('git status --porcelain');
if (status) throw new Error(`Working tree not clean:\n${status}`);
// No stale locks
if (existsSync(join(ROOT, '.git', 'index.lock'))) {
throw new Error('Stale .git/index.lock found — remove it first');
}
// Not detached HEAD
try { execStrict('git symbolic-ref HEAD'); }
catch { throw new Error('Detached HEAD — checkout a branch first'); }
}
/** Phase 5: Run verify command and extract metric */
private runVerify(): number | null {
this.log(' verify...');
const output = exec(this.config.verify, { timeout: 300_000 });
return extractMetric(output);
}
/** Phase 5.5: Run guard command */
private runGuard(): boolean {
if (!this.config.guard) return true;
this.log(' guard...');
try {
execStrict(this.config.guard, { timeout: 300_000 });
return true;
} catch {
return false;
}
}
/** Phase 4: Commit changes */
private commit(description: string): string | null {
// Stage all changes in scope (but not untracked outside scope)
exec('git add -A');
const diff = exec('git diff --cached --quiet; echo $?');
if (diff === '0') return null; // no changes
try {
execStrict(`git commit -m "experiment(operate): ${description.replace(/"/g, '\\"')}"`);
return exec('git rev-parse --short HEAD');
} catch {
// Hook failure
exec('git reset HEAD');
return 'hook-blocked';
}
}
/** Phase 6: Rollback */
private safeRevert(): void {
try {
execStrict('git revert HEAD --no-edit');
} catch {
exec('git revert --abort');
exec('git reset --hard HEAD~1');
}
}
/** Get stuck hint when >5 consecutive discards */
private getStuckHint(discards: number): string | null {
if (discards < 5) return null;
const hints = [
'Re-read ALL scope files from scratch. Try a completely different approach.',
'Review entire results log — what worked before? Try combining successful changes.',
'Try the OPPOSITE of what has been failing.',
'Try a radical architectural change instead of incremental tweaks.',
'Simplify — remove complexity rather than adding it.',
];
return hints[Math.min(discards - 5, hints.length - 1)];
}
/** Run the main loop */
async run(): Promise<IterationResult[]> {
const results: IterationResult[] = [];
// Phase 0: Preconditions
this.log('Phase 0: Precondition checks...');
this.checkPreconditions();
// Initialize logger
this.logger.init(this.config);
// Baseline measurement
this.log('Measuring baseline...');
const baseline = this.runVerify();
if (baseline == null) throw new Error('Verify command returned no metric for baseline');
this.bestMetric = baseline;
this.currentMetric = baseline;
const baselineCommit = exec('git rev-parse --short HEAD');
const baselineResult: IterationResult = {
iteration: 0,
commit: baselineCommit,
metric: baseline,
delta: 0,
guard: this.config.guard ? (this.runGuard() ? 'pass' : 'fail') : '-',
status: 'baseline',
description: `initial state — ${this.config.metric} ${baseline}`,
};
this.logger.append(baselineResult);
results.push(baselineResult);
this.log(`Baseline: ${this.config.metric} = ${baseline}`);
// Main loop
const maxIter = this.config.iterations ?? Infinity;
for (this.iteration = 1; this.iteration <= maxIter; this.iteration++) {
this.log(`\n━━━ Iteration ${this.iteration}${maxIter < Infinity ? `/${maxIter}` : ''} ━━━`);
// Phase 1: Review
const gitLog = exec('git log --oneline -20');
const recentLog = this.logger.readLast(20);
const scopeFiles = this.config.scope;
const consecutiveDiscards = this.logger.consecutiveDiscards();
// Phase 2-3: Ideate + Modify (delegated to callback)
const context: ModifyContext = {
iteration: this.iteration,
bestMetric: this.bestMetric,
currentMetric: this.currentMetric,
recentLog,
gitLog,
scopeFiles,
consecutiveDiscards,
stuckHint: this.getStuckHint(consecutiveDiscards),
};
let description: string | null;
try {
description = await this.callbacks.modify(context);
} catch (err: any) {
this.log(` modify error: ${err.message}`);
const result: IterationResult = {
iteration: this.iteration,
commit: '-',
metric: this.currentMetric,
delta: 0,
guard: '-',
status: 'crash',
description: `modify crashed: ${err.message?.slice(0, 80)}`,
};
this.logger.append(result);
results.push(result);
continue;
}
if (!description) {
const result: IterationResult = {
iteration: this.iteration,
commit: '-',
metric: this.currentMetric,
delta: 0,
guard: '-',
status: 'no-op',
description: 'no changes made',
};
this.logger.append(result);
results.push(result);
continue;
}
// Phase 4: Commit
this.log(` commit: ${description}`);
const commitHash = this.commit(description);
if (!commitHash) {
const result: IterationResult = {
iteration: this.iteration,
commit: '-',
metric: this.currentMetric,
delta: 0,
guard: '-',
status: 'no-op',
description: `no diff after: ${description}`,
};
this.logger.append(result);
results.push(result);
continue;
}
if (commitHash === 'hook-blocked') {
const result: IterationResult = {
iteration: this.iteration,
commit: '-',
metric: this.currentMetric,
delta: 0,
guard: '-',
status: 'hook-blocked',
description: `hook rejected: ${description}`,
};
this.logger.append(result);
results.push(result);
continue;
}
// Phase 5: Verify
const metric = this.runVerify();
if (metric == null) {
this.log(' verify crashed — reverting');
this.safeRevert();
const result: IterationResult = {
iteration: this.iteration,
commit: '-',
metric: this.currentMetric,
delta: 0,
guard: '-',
status: 'crash',
description: `verify crashed: ${description}`,
};
this.logger.append(result);
results.push(result);
continue;
}
const improved = this.config.direction === 'higher'
? metric > this.bestMetric
: metric < this.bestMetric;
const delta = +(metric - this.bestMetric).toFixed(4);
const absDelta = Math.abs(delta);
const minDelta = this.config.minDelta ?? 0;
// Phase 5.5: Guard
let guardResult: 'pass' | 'fail' | '-' = '-';
if (this.config.guard && improved && absDelta >= minDelta) {
guardResult = this.runGuard() ? 'pass' : 'fail';
}
// Phase 6: Decide
let status: IterationStatus;
if (improved && absDelta >= minDelta && (guardResult !== 'fail')) {
status = 'keep';
this.bestMetric = metric;
this.currentMetric = metric;
this.log(` ✓ KEEP — ${this.config.metric}: ${metric} (${delta >= 0 ? '+' : ''}${delta})`);
} else if (improved && guardResult === 'fail') {
this.log(' guard failed — reverting');
this.safeRevert();
status = 'discard';
this.log(` ✗ DISCARD (guard) — ${description}`);
} else {
this.safeRevert();
status = 'discard';
const reason = absDelta < minDelta ? 'below min delta' : 'no improvement';
this.log(` ✗ DISCARD (${reason}) — ${this.config.metric}: ${metric} (${delta >= 0 ? '+' : ''}${delta})`);
}
const result: IterationResult = {
iteration: this.iteration,
commit: status === 'keep' ? commitHash : '-',
metric,
delta,
guard: guardResult,
status,
description,
};
this.logger.append(result);
results.push(result);
}
// Summary
const keeps = results.filter(r => r.status === 'keep' || r.status === 'keep (reworked)');
const discards = results.filter(r => r.status === 'discard');
this.log(`\n${'━'.repeat(50)}`);
this.log(`Done: ${this.iteration - 1} iterations, ${keeps.length} kept, ${discards.length} discarded`);
this.log(`Final ${this.config.metric}: ${this.bestMetric} (started at ${results[0]?.metric})`);
return results;
}
}