copilotkit__copilotkit/showcase/TESTING.md

Showcase Testing

Tagline: bin/showcase test reference, cell red→green SOP, per-demo coverage matrix, and CI gating matrix.

Three concerns live here:

1. Cell red→green SOP and bin/showcase test CLI reference — how to run the harness locally and how to drive a cell from red to green.
2. Per-Demo Coverage Matrix — what test surface exists for each demo across manual QA, unit, E2E, and aimock.
3. CI gating matrix — which CI workflows fire on which triggers and whether they gate merges.

Operational gotchas (aimock fixture caching, --isolate slot collisions, etc.) live in GOTCHAS.md. Per-failure-mode debugging strategies and production-side ops (probe triggering, Railway log access, isolated stack cleanup) live in DEBUGGING.md.

bin/showcase test invocation semantics

--d5 / --d6 route through the production-equivalent control-plane pipeline (producer → queue → worker, same as Railway). --direct switches to a legacy in-process driver (bypasses control-plane).

Invocation	Family	Pipeline	Per-demo scoping (:demo)
--d5 (no :demo)	d5 representative	control-plane	hardcoded agentic-chat
--d5 :demo	d5 single demo	control-plane	honored (post-A18)
--d5 --direct	d5 family	in-process	honored via buildDeepInputs
--d6 (no :demo)	d6 full sweep	control-plane	full demo list, aggregate validation
--d6 :demo	d6 single demo	control-plane	honored (post-A18)
--d6 --direct	d6 family	in-process	honored via buildFullInputs
--direct (no --d5/--d6)	d5+d6 default	in-process	honored

Use control-plane (no --direct) for production-equivalent testing. It exercises the same producer→queue→worker pipeline Railway uses, so local results are apples-to-apples with staging. --direct is opt-out legacy: useful for fast in-process debugging when you don't need the queue.

--isolate (post-A21+A21b) scopes the rebuild to the target slug — infra services (aimock, pocketbase, dashboard, harness, harness-pool-worker) reuse cached images from the local Docker store. Cold-build is ~30s–2 min per slug instead of 10+ min full-stack rebuild.

SOP: turning a cell red → green

1. Run the harness LOCALLY FIRST. Capture the RED log via the production-equivalent path BEFORE any code change:

   bin/showcase test <slug>:<demo> --d5 --isolate
   

   No theory, no "should work" — observe the actual failure.

2. One change. Verify GREEN locally on the same probe. Re-run the same invocation; it must go green. Iterate if not. Don't commit on red.

3. LGP regression check every time. Gold-standard cell must stay green:

   bin/showcase test langgraph-python:tool-rendering-custom-catchall --d5 --isolate
   

4. Diagnose by failure mode (use the aimock /journal endpoint + docker logs showcase-iso<N>-aimock + DOM/probe text):

   • Backend doesn't loop after tool_result → backend fix (add tool handler, fix agentId routing). See crewai-crews for the canonical example.
   • toolCallId-gated narration fixture doesn't match → backend rewrites IDs (Anthropic toolu_*, TanStack fc-*). Fix: swap toolCallId discriminator for turnIndex (or hasToolResult / sequenceIndex) — backend-id-invariant. See built-in-agent and claude-sdk-typescript for canonical match-key tunes.
   • No fixture entry matches the probe's userMessage → add the entry following the existing match-shape conventions.
   • Probe scan returns false despite phrase visibly in DOM → harness/probe bug.

5. Layer boundaries:

   • Fixtures: per-integration freedom. Do NOT modify response.content (canonical narration is fixture-author truth — the d5 probe asserts on it; a real LLM won't reliably emit the verbatim phrase). Tune match keys instead.
   • Backends: minimal. Faithfully echo aimock prescriptions where possible; close the tool-loop with a second LLM call after tool_result. Don't expand backend logic when a fixture match-key change suffices.
   • Tests: identical across integrations (the d5 probe is shared).
   • Frontends: near-identical — don't touch in cell-fix scope.
   • LGP is gold standard. Diff against langgraph-python's fixture/backend pattern, not the sibling-of-the-day.

6. aimock matcher semantics (for /v1/responses after responsesInputToMessages transform; identical to /v1/chat/completions):

   Match key	Semantics
   userMessage	substring on the last role:"user" message
   toolCallId	strict equality vs last role:"tool" tool_call_id (FRAGILE — backend ID-rewrite breaks this)
   hasToolResult	boolean: any role:"tool" message present
   turnIndex	integer: count of role:"assistant" messages
   context	equality vs x-aimock-context header

   First-match-wins. Order entries specific-before-generic.

7. aimock caches fixtures at container startup. Editing a fixture in a live stack requires docker restart showcase-iso<N>-aimock to reload. Fresh --isolate slots cold-start aimock from the volume mount, so the first post-edit run picks up the change automatically; warm-slot reuse will not.

8. --isolate slot collisions with foreign Docker projects. The slot registry only knows about showcase-* compose projects. If a sibling project (e.g., ag2mm-*) owns the same host ports for the auto-picked slot, health checks cross to the wrong containers and results misroute. Either pre-reserve the conflicting slot dirs in ~/.local/state/copilotkit/showcase/slots/ or tear down the foreign stack first.

9. Cell-color flip claims MUST be empirically value-tested via the production-equivalent control-plane path on ≥3 candidate cells before merge. No "should flip N." Use:

   bin/showcase test <slug>:<feature> --d6 --isolate
   

   (or --d5 --isolate for single-pill e2e). DO NOT use --direct for value-test — it bypasses the queue/worker pipeline staging actually runs and has misled investigations in the past.

10. No fixture rewrite from real-LLM record/replay. The canonical-phrase probe is anti-record/replay-against-real-LLM by construction: a real LLM won't emit the verbatim assertion phrase. Fixture content is authored truth; tune the match keys to fire on the right turn.

Per-Demo Coverage Matrix

Tagline: what test surface exists per demo. PASS=covered, WARN=partial, FAIL=none, STUB=needs aimock fixture.

Demo Coverage

Demo	Manual QA	Vitest Unit	Playwright E2E (smoke)	Playwright E2E (interaction)	Per-Package E2E	Aimock Fixtures	CI Auto
Agentic Chat	PASS 17 packages	FAIL	PASS load + suggestions	WARN suggestion click only	PASS weather card, background change, multi-turn	WARN background, weather matches	WARN validate only (no Playwright in CI by default)
Human in the Loop	PASS 17 packages	FAIL	PASS load + suggestions	WARN suggestion click only	PASS step selector, approve/reject	WARN plan/steps/mars matches (text only, no interrupt)	WARN validate only
Tool Rendering	PASS 17 packages	FAIL	PASS load + suggestions	WARN suggestion click only	PASS WeatherCard with stats grid	WARN weather match (tool call)	WARN validate only
Gen UI (Tool-Based)	PASS 17 packages	FAIL	FAIL	FAIL	PASS sidebar, haiku card, pie/bar chart	FAIL no haiku-specific fixture	WARN validate only
Gen UI (Agent)	PASS 17 packages	FAIL	FAIL	FAIL	PASS task progress tracker, progress bar	FAIL no gen-ui-agent fixture	WARN validate only
Shared State (Read)	PASS 17 packages	FAIL	FAIL	FAIL	PASS recipe card, sidebar, pipeline	FAIL no shared-state fixture	WARN validate only
Shared State (Write)	PASS 17 packages (stub)	FAIL	FAIL	FAIL	PASS pipeline, deal CRUD, agent state writes	FAIL no shared-state fixture	WARN validate only
Shared State (Streaming)	PASS 17 packages (stub)	FAIL	FAIL	FAIL	PASS document editor, confirm/reject changes	FAIL no streaming fixture	WARN validate only
Sub-Agents	PASS 17 packages (stub)	FAIL	FAIL	FAIL	PASS travel planner, agent indicators, sections	FAIL no subagent fixture	WARN validate only

Starter Hero Coverage

Feature	Manual QA	Vitest Unit	Playwright E2E (smoke)	Playwright E2E (interaction)	Aimock Fixtures	CI Auto
Sales Dashboard (page load)	FAIL	PASS extract-starter tests (on-demand extraction)	PASS header, 4 renderer pills	PASS pill switching, content verification	WARN sales/todo/deal matches	WARN validate + aimock-e2e (manual trigger)
Renderer Selector	FAIL	FAIL	PASS 4 pills visible, default selection	PASS mutual exclusion, content changes per mode	FAIL	WARN validate only
Tool-Based mode	FAIL	FAIL	PASS pipeline heading, KPI cards	PASS Add a deal, multiple deals, empty state	WARN sales/todo matches	WARN validate only
A2UI Catalog mode	FAIL	FAIL	PASS same pipeline content	FAIL	FAIL	WARN validate only
json-render mode	FAIL	FAIL	PASS fallback note + pipeline	FAIL	FAIL	WARN validate only
HashBrown mode	FAIL	FAIL	PASS pipeline content	FAIL	FAIL	WARN validate only

Probe Depth Coverage

Depth	Probe Name	Cadence	What "Green" Means
D5	e2e-demos	hourly :10	All per-integration smoke probes pass
D6	d6-all-pills-e2e	hourly :40	All demo cells pass across every integration pill

Test Infrastructure Locations

• Manual QA: showcase/integrations/*/qa/*.md (153 files, 17 packages × 9 demos).
• Vitest unit: showcase/scripts/__tests__/*.test.ts — registry/constraint/bundle/integration generators.
• Shared E2E: showcase/scripts/__tests__/e2e/ — starter-e2e.spec.ts, demo-e2e.spec.ts, screenshots.spec.ts.
• Per-package E2E: showcase/integrations/*/tests/e2e/ — 9 demo specs per package; langgraph-python adds renderer-selector.spec.ts.
• Aimock fixtures: showcase/aimock/ — feature-parity.json, smoke.json, d4/<slug>/, d6/<slug>/.
• CI: .github/workflows/showcase_*.yml (see Test-Gating Matrix below).

Known coverage gaps

1. No aimock fixtures for haiku, recipe/deals/document state, travel planning, HITL interrupt.
2. No shared E2E for gen-ui-tool-based, gen-ui-agent, shared-state-*, subagents.
3. No automatic Playwright E2E in CI on every PR; aimock E2E requires /test-aimock comment.
4. No Sales Dashboard starter manual QA checklists.
5. Renderer-selector per-package E2E exists only for langgraph-python.

Test-Gating Matrix

This matrix documents which CI workflows fire on which triggers, what they test, and whether they gate merges.

Scope: all testing-related workflows (unit, integration, e2e, smoke) across the monorepo. Data read directly from .github/workflows/*.yml on the current branch.

Matrix

Workflow file	Name (CI UI)	Trigger	Path filter	Required?	What it tests
.github/workflows/test_unit.yml	test / unit	push (main), pull_request (main), workflow_dispatch	paths-ignore: docs/**, README.md, examples/**	No	Vitest unit suite across Node 20/22/24 for all TS packages
.github/workflows/test_unit-python-sdk.yml	test / unit / python-sdk	push (main), pull_request (main)	sdk-python/**, this workflow	No	pytest against sdk-python/ under Python 3.12 + Poetry
.github/workflows/test_integration-runtime.yml	test / integration / runtime	push (main), pull_request (main), workflow_dispatch	packages/runtime/**, this workflow	No	Runtime server integration tests (Node, possibly others)
.github/workflows/test_integration-docs.yml	test / integration / docs	push (main), pull_request	docs/**	No	Extracts code blocks from docs, runs them against aimock (model-name + doc-test)
.github/workflows/test_e2e-dojo.yml	test / e2e / dojo	push (main), pull_request (main), workflow_dispatch	packages/**, sdk-python/**, this workflow, .changeset	No	ag-ui dojo end-to-end matrix on Depot runners
.github/workflows/test_e2e-legacy-v1.yml	test / e2e / legacy-v1	push (main), pull_request (main), workflow_dispatch	examples/**, this workflow, .changeset	No	Legacy v1.x examples (form-filling, travel, research-canvas, chat-with-your-data, state-machine)
.github/workflows/showcase_validate.yml	Showcase: Validate	push (main), pull_request	showcase/**, examples/integrations/**/fixtures/**, scripts/doc-tests/fixtures/**	No	Build-pipeline Vitest + manifest/registry validation + shell build
.github/workflows/test_e2e-showcase-on-demand.yml	test / e2e / showcase / on-demand	issue_comment (/test-aimock), workflow_dispatch	n/a (comment-gated)	No	aimock-backed Playwright E2E on demand per-package
.github/workflows/test_smoke-starter.yml	test / smoke / starter	schedule (0 */6 * * *), workflow_run (publish / release), pull_request, workflow_dispatch	examples/integrations/**, this workflow	No	Docker-compose smoke for 12 starter integrations (build + curl)
.github/workflows/test_smoke-starter-deployed.yml	test / smoke / starter-deployed	schedule (0 */6 * * *), workflow_run (Showcase: Build & Deploy), workflow_dispatch	n/a (scheduled / post-deploy)	No	Playwright E2E against live deployed starter URLs (@starter-health/-agent/-chat)

Which tests run on a typical PR?

• packages/** (runtime/SDK): test / unit, test / integration, test / e2e / dojo, static / quality, static / check binaries, plus static / danger if packages/sdk-js/src/langgraph.ts is touched.
• sdk-python/**: test / unit / python-sdk, test / e2e / dojo, static / check binaries, plus static / danger if copilotkit/langgraph_agent.py is touched. test / unit also fires (paths-ignore does not exclude sdk-python).
• showcase/**: Showcase: Validate, test / unit (paths-ignore does not exclude showcase), static / quality, static / check binaries. No Playwright E2E runs automatically -- comment /test-aimock on the PR to trigger test / e2e / showcase / on-demand.
• examples/** (legacy v1.x): test / e2e / legacy-v1, static / check binaries. test / unit is excluded via paths-ignore.
• examples/integrations/** (starters): test / smoke / starter (Docker), Showcase: Validate (for fixtures only), static / check binaries.
• docs/**: test / integration / docs only. test / unit and static / quality are excluded via paths-ignore.
• .github/workflows/**: each workflow that lists its own path in its trigger runs (most do). No single "workflows changed" catch-all.

Required status checks

None of the workflows above are enforced as required status checks. The active PROTECT_OUR_MAIN ruleset on main requires zero status contexts -- merges are gated only by review approval, not by CI outcome.

The legacy classic branch protection required_status_checks.contexts array contains stale entries (e.g. test / unit, Showcase: Validate) that appear in GitHub's API responses but are not evaluated by the active ruleset. If you see a CI workflow marked as "required" in an older doc or script, treat that as ghost data: nothing in GitHub's current enforcement path consumes it.

Practical consequence: a red CI run does not block merge. Reviewers must eyeball gh pr checks before approving.

Footnotes

• test / unit matrix is Node 20/22/24; the other workflows pin a single Node version each (22 most common).
• test / e2e / dojo uses Depot runners (depot-ubuntu-24.04); all others use standard GitHub runners.
• test / smoke / starter and test / smoke / starter-deployed both run every 6h; the former validates Docker-build integrity of examples/integrations/, the latter validates the deployed Railway services.
• workflow_run triggers fire after another workflow completes -- they do not gate the triggering PR, they run post-merge.