Files
copilotkit__copilotkit/showcase/bin/spec/test_snapshot_ivar_lint.rb
Jordan Ritter cc9c3a02b5 docs(showcase): make promote --help banner truthful
The `bin/railway promote` help banner advertised preflight checks and
effects that were never implemented in any commit (verified via full
git history on showcase/bin/railway — all phrases trace to the original
56e85dfd80 add, never as working logic):

- MOVES "autoUpdate=disabled flag": execute_promotion only pins the prod
  image digest + redeploys (serviceInstanceUpdate sets source.image only);
  auto_updates_disabled is a vestigial snapshot field hardcoded to nil and
  never mutated.
- VERIFY-REFUSE "PB superuser auth" / "PB collection parity": no such
  checks exist; POCKETBASE_SUPERUSER_* are only key-presence entries in
  CRITICAL_ENV_KEYS, and PocketBase auth/collection logic lives entirely in
  the harness, never reached by promote.
- VERIFY-REFUSE "cross-env URL leak scan": never implemented; snapshots
  capture env-key NAMES only (values are never compared), making such a
  scan impossible by construction.
- WARN "sealed-var heuristics": isSealed is fetched in the env-vars query
  but never read; no heuristic consumes it.

Rewrite MOVES/VERIFY-REFUSE/WARN/IGNORE to list only the real preflight
(P1 GHCR digest, P2 staging deployment + race, P3 staging live-green, P6
startCommand/healthcheckPath/image-shape parity, service-set parity,
critical env-key parity; P6 region/replicas/restartPolicy/env-key-set and
expected-prod-domains WARNs) and the real effect (pin prod image to the
staging digest + redeploy). Doc-text-only; no logic changed.

Renumber test_snapshot_ivar_lint.rb ALLOWED_LINES by +3 to track the
line shift from the (longer) banner — the lint is line-number-pinned by
design and instructs hand-renumbering on any shift above its region.
2026-06-08 12:06:27 -07:00

133 lines
6.4 KiB
Ruby

# frozen_string_literal: true
# Snapshot-ivar enforcement lint.
#
# Background: PromoteCommand has two snapshot "views" — the FULL un-narrowed
# fleet snapshot and the (optionally) target-narrowed snapshot. Two prior
# regressions came from a `check_*` method reading the wrong raw ivar
# (`@staging_snapshot` / `@prod_snapshot`) inside a fleet-scoped invariant
# and accidentally evaluating it against the narrowed view, producing
# spurious WARN/REFUSE findings on single-service promotes.
#
# The fix introduced four accessors — `fleet_staging`, `fleet_prod`,
# `target_staging`, `target_prod` — and the convention is that ALL reads of
# the four backing ivars go through one of those accessors. This lint test
# pins the convention as an executable invariant: any direct read of
# `@staging_snapshot`, `@prod_snapshot`, `@full_staging_snapshot`, or
# `@full_prod_snapshot` outside the explicit allowlist below FAILS the
# suite.
#
# The allowlist is keyed by `<line-number>:<exact-line-content>` and the
# check requires BOTH to match. NOTE: the allowlist is keyed by both line
# number and stripped content. Any line shift in bin/railway above the
# allowlisted region requires renumbering every entry by hand; the
# `test_allowlist_entries_match_current_file_content` self-check fails
# loud when this drifts. Nothing refreshes the allowlist mechanically —
# this dual self-check + offender-sweep is intentional, so a new
# offender (even one with identical surrounding text) fails the suite.
#
# To intentionally add a NEW legitimate write/accessor site, also add its
# `<line>:<content>` entry to ALLOWED_LINES.
require_relative "spec_helper"
class SnapshotIvarLintTest < Minitest::Test
RAILWAY_PATH = File.expand_path("../railway", __dir__)
# The four protected ivars. Anything matching one of these names is a
# candidate offender unless it appears on an allowlisted line.
IVAR_PATTERN = /@(?:full_)?(?:staging|prod)_snapshot\b/.freeze
# Allowlist: every legitimate site that mentions one of the four
# ivars. Format = "<1-indexed line>:<stripped line content>". When the
# railway file legitimately changes, update this list to match.
#
# Categories (must remain in sync with bin/railway):
# - run : initial @full_*_snapshot capture at promote start
# - capture_snapshots
# : the single test-seam assignment site
# - narrow_snapshots_to_single_service!
# : the narrowing reads + writes of @{staging,prod}_snapshot
# - fleet_staging / fleet_prod / target_staging / target_prod
# : the four accessors themselves (the ONLY sanctioned reads)
# - comments : block/inline comments that name the ivar in
# prose (do not perform a read)
ALLOWED_LINES = [
# `run` — capture full-fleet view before optional narrowing.
'1224:@full_staging_snapshot = @staging_snapshot',
'1225:@full_prod_snapshot = @prod_snapshot',
# Doc comment above narrow_snapshots_to_single_service!.
'1233:# Narrow @staging_snapshot and @prod_snapshot to only the named',
# narrow_snapshots_to_single_service! — the WRITE site.
'1241:staging_match = (@staging_snapshot["services"] || []).select { |s| s["name"] == name }',
'1246:@staging_snapshot = @staging_snapshot.merge("services" => staging_match)',
'1247:prod_match = (@prod_snapshot["services"] || []).select { |s| s["name"] == name }',
'1248:@prod_snapshot = @prod_snapshot.merge("services" => prod_match)',
# Doc comment above capture_snapshots.
'1252:# @staging_snapshot / @prod_snapshot directly.',
# capture_snapshots — single test-seam assignment site.
'1254:@staging_snapshot ||= SnapshotCommand.new(["--env", "staging", "--dry-run"]).build_snapshot(STAGING_ENV_ID)',
'1255:@prod_snapshot ||= SnapshotCommand.new(["--env", "production", "--dry-run"]).build_snapshot(PRODUCTION_ENV_ID)',
# Doc comment above the accessor block (explains test seam).
'1279:# promote tests stub @staging_snapshot/@prod_snapshot directly',
# The four accessor bodies — the ONLY sanctioned reads.
'1291:@full_staging_snapshot || @staging_snapshot',
'1295:@full_prod_snapshot || @prod_snapshot',
'1299:@staging_snapshot',
'1303:@prod_snapshot',
].freeze
def setup
@lines = File.readlines(RAILWAY_PATH).each_with_index.map { |l, i| [i + 1, l.chomp] }
@allowed = ALLOWED_LINES.each_with_object({}) do |entry, h|
lineno, content = entry.split(":", 2)
h[Integer(lineno)] = content
end
end
def test_allowlist_entries_match_current_file_content
# Defensive: prove the allowlist itself is correct. If someone
# reformats bin/railway and the allowlist drifts, surface that as
# a clear assertion rather than a spurious lint failure later.
@allowed.each do |lineno, expected|
actual = @lines.find { |n, _| n == lineno }
assert actual, "allowlist references line #{lineno} but railway has no such line"
assert_equal expected, actual[1].strip,
"allowlist content for line #{lineno} does not match railway file " \
"(allowlist=#{expected.inspect}, file=#{actual[1].strip.inspect}). " \
"If the file legitimately changed, update ALLOWED_LINES."
end
end
def test_no_direct_ivar_reads_outside_allowlist
offenders = []
@lines.each do |lineno, content|
next unless content =~ IVAR_PATTERN
next if @allowed.key?(lineno) && @allowed[lineno] == content.strip
offenders << " #{RAILWAY_PATH}:#{lineno}: #{content.strip}"
end
assert_empty offenders, <<~MSG
Direct read of @{,full_}{staging,prod}_snapshot found outside the
sanctioned write/accessor sites. ALL reads must go through one
of the four accessors:
fleet_staging / fleet_prod — FLEET-shape invariants
target_staging / target_prod — per-service checks
Offenders:
#{offenders.join("\n")}
If this site is a legitimate new write or accessor, add its
"<line>:<stripped content>" entry to ALLOWED_LINES in
#{__FILE__} and document why.
MSG
end
end