Files
callstack__agent-device/scripts/check-affected/model.ts
Michał Pierzchała eb3fc5b28d chore: scan packages/** with fallow instead of ignoring it (#1591)
`ignorePatterns: ["packages/**"]` landed in #1494 W0 with the recorded
reason "its resolver cannot follow workspace specifiers". That was either
wrong at the time or never re-checked: the fallow version has not moved
(^2.95.0 then and now) and it resolves @agent-device/* through each
package's exports map today. packages/kernel alone exposes 8 subpaths and
~110 exports reachable only via workspace specifiers, and scanning it
reports zero findings — a resolver that could not follow the specifier
would report all of them.

The cost of the ignore is that every package extraction silently removes
its code from dead-code analysis. #1589 moved the selector engine into
packages/selectors/ and shipped a façade with 15 zero-consumer exports,
including `selectorUsesKey`, written in that PR and never called. A
follow-up commit removed them by hand; nothing would have caught them.

Removing the pattern surfaced 43 findings, driven to zero by deleting the
dead code rather than by baselining or excluding it (fallow-baselines/*.json
are empty on purpose — the posture is fix-or-document-the-exemption, so a
first baseline entry would be a policy change):

- 38 are deleted. 24 façade type re-exports whose only claim was that a
  consumer might one day want to name them — typecheck is green without
  every one, so the claim was theoretical; 5 façade value re-exports; 9
  `export` keywords on symbols used only inside their own file. Every
  deleted façade symbol comes off scripts/layering/facade-symbols.ts (and
  ad-replay's inline pin in package-boundaries.test.ts) in the same change,
  so R11 is narrowed with the façade, never weakened around it.
- 4 stale suppressions in src/provider-limrun-runtime.ts existed only
  because packages/ was invisible.
- 5 have consumers analysis genuinely cannot see, and get an
  `ignoreExports` entry naming the consumer per the existing `comment`
  convention: four test-tree importers that --production does not walk, and
  `LimrunIosCommandExecution`, which src/sdk/limrun.ts republishes as
  agent-device/limrun — its only importer compiles in a temp checkout, so
  no static edge reaches it. test/integration/limrun-public-types.test.ts
  is the standing proof that one is real API.

Three doc comments named types their façade no longer exports and are
corrected rather than left asserting something false — including #1555's
claim in session-replay-target-verification.ts that the daemon imports
`AdReplayVerifiedTargetGuard` directly. It does not; it reaches that shape
through `AdReplayTargetClassification`/`AdReplayDispatchGuard`, which is
why the name read as dead.

`scripts/maestro-conformance/**` was ignored wholesale to cover its corpus
data. Narrowed to `corpus/**`, which un-hides the tooling beside it and
turned up one more file-local export (`buildManifest`); regenerate.mjs's
importer of `fixtureContentHash` becomes visible, so that needs no
exemption at all.

scripts/check-affected/model.ts deliberately did not select the `fallow`
check for packages/*/src/**, carrying the same stale rationale as a
comment. Without that selection the new scope would never run in the
affected-driven lane, so the ignore removal would have bought nothing.
model.test.ts now pins the selection.

Verified: check:fallow and check:production-exports green with packages in
scope; full-repo `fallow dead-code` back to its one pre-existing finding;
typecheck, layering (R11), lint, format, build, check:package, and the
limrun published-types integration test all pass. Probed by adding a fresh
zero-consumer export to the xml façade — check:production-exports reports
it, so the #1589 case now fails the gate.

Co-authored-by: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
2026-08-04 18:26:03 +02:00

452 lines
14 KiB
TypeScript

// Derived, fail-open check selector for `pnpm check:affected --base <ref>`.
//
// The model turns a set of changed paths into a plan of local checks with
// stable, machine-readable reasoning. It is intentionally source-of-truth
// derived rather than a hand-maintained path-to-check registry (issue #1181):
//
// - Vitest owns affected-test discovery through its native `related`
// command and static module graph; this model only decides when that
// existing tool applies;
// - the lint/typecheck/layering/fallow gates are always-on for their input
// categories, so they are never silently skipped (issue constraint);
// - a small explicit build-ownership layer covers Swift, Android helpers,
// the macOS helper, MCP metadata, and the public package surface — the
// only paths whose owning build the sources of truth cannot derive.
//
// Anything the model cannot confidently classify fails open to the full check
// set: unknown paths, workflow/tooling, the selector's own sources, and
// ambiguous files under an owned root that only resolve to `format` (e.g. a
// non-.ts fixture whose owning suite cannot be derived). Existing GitHub CI
// remains authoritative; this only optimizes local/agent feedback.
export type CheckId =
| 'format'
| 'lint'
| 'typecheck'
| 'test-app-typecheck'
| 'layering'
| 'fallow'
| 'mcp-metadata'
| 'build'
| 'package'
| 'vitest-related'
| 'unit'
| 'coverage'
| 'provider-integration'
| 'integration-node'
| 'integration-progress'
| 'swift-runner'
| 'android-helpers'
| 'macos-helper'
| 'web-smoke'
| 'replay-compat';
// The complete local check universe. A fail-open plan selects all of these;
// keep it in sync with the catalog in checks.ts (asserted by the self-test).
export const ALL_CHECKS: readonly CheckId[] = [
'format',
'lint',
'typecheck',
'test-app-typecheck',
'layering',
'fallow',
'mcp-metadata',
'build',
'package',
'vitest-related',
'unit',
'coverage',
'provider-integration',
'integration-node',
'integration-progress',
'swift-runner',
'android-helpers',
'macos-helper',
'web-smoke',
'replay-compat',
];
export type SelectionReason = {
check: CheckId;
path: string;
rule: string;
detail: string;
};
export type FailOpenReason = {
path: string;
rule: 'workflow-tooling' | 'selector-owning' | 'unknown-path' | 'ambiguous-path';
detail: string;
};
export type CheckPlan = {
failOpen: boolean;
checks: CheckId[];
reasons: SelectionReason[];
failOpenReasons: FailOpenReason[];
docsOnlyPaths: string[];
};
export type SelectInput = {
changedFiles: readonly string[];
// Public package entry source files, derived from package.json `exports`.
packageEntryFiles?: readonly string[];
};
// --- Path classification helpers -------------------------------------------
const ROOT_TOOLING = new Set([
'package.json',
'pnpm-lock.yaml',
'pnpm-workspace.yaml',
'tsconfig.json',
'tsconfig.lib.json',
'tsdown.config.ts',
'vitest.config.ts',
'.oxlintrc.json',
'.oxfmtrc.json',
'.npmrc',
]);
// Prose that specifies this selector's own behavior — the Testing Matrix these
// ownership rules mirror. It is docs by path, but editing it can invalidate the
// derivation below, and the selector cannot tell whether it did. Keep this in
// sync when the matrix moves; the docs short-circuit would otherwise treat it as
// inert Markdown.
const SELECTOR_OWNING_DOCS = new Set(['docs/agents/testing.md']);
function isSelectorOwning(file: string): boolean {
return (
SELECTOR_OWNING_DOCS.has(file) ||
(file.startsWith('scripts/check-affected/') && !file.endsWith('.md'))
);
}
function isWorkflowTooling(file: string): boolean {
// A workspace package manifest or tsconfig rewires module resolution for
// every consumer, so it fails open like root tooling does.
const packageTooling = /^packages\/[^/]+\/(?:package\.json|tsconfig\.json)$/.test(file);
return (
file.startsWith('.github/') ||
file.startsWith('scripts/') ||
packageTooling ||
ROOT_TOOLING.has(file)
);
}
function isDocs(file: string): boolean {
// skills/ Markdown is agent guidance prose with no owning suite (the
// SkillGym harness was removed), so it classifies as docs like the rest.
return (
file.startsWith('docs/') ||
file.startsWith('website/') ||
file === 'README.md' ||
file === 'LICENSE' ||
file.endsWith('.md')
);
}
function isTestPath(file: string): boolean {
return /\.test\.ts$/.test(file) || /(?:^|\/)__tests__\//.test(file);
}
// --- Ownership rules --------------------------------------------------------
// Each rule inspects one changed file and returns the reasons it contributes.
// Splitting the selection into small, independent rules keeps every function
// simple and makes the derivation self-documenting.
type FileFacts = {
file: string;
isTs: boolean;
underSrc: boolean;
underTest: boolean;
isSrcProd: boolean;
};
type OwnershipRule = (facts: FileFacts, input: SelectInput) => SelectionReason[];
function reason(check: CheckId, file: string, rule: string, detail: string): SelectionReason {
return { check, path: file, rule, detail };
}
const formatGate: OwnershipRule = ({ file, underSrc, underTest }) =>
underSrc || underTest
? [reason('format', file, 'gate:format', 'oxfmt covers src/ and test/')]
: [];
const staticTsGates: OwnershipRule = ({ file, isTs, underSrc, underTest }) =>
isTs && (underSrc || underTest)
? [
reason('lint', file, 'gate:lint', 'oxlint covers the source tree'),
reason('typecheck', file, 'gate:typecheck', 'tsc includes src/ and test/'),
reason('fallow', file, 'gate:fallow', 'fallow audits changed TypeScript for dead code'),
]
: [];
const srcProdGate: OwnershipRule = ({ file, isSrcProd }) => {
if (!isSrcProd) return [];
const selections = [
reason('layering', file, 'gate:layering', 'layering guard reads production src/ modules'),
reason('build', file, 'src-prod', 'production source is compiled by the build'),
];
if (file.startsWith('src/platforms/')) {
selections.push(
reason(
'provider-integration',
file,
'platform-src',
'platform source shapes device/provider wire behavior',
),
reason(
'coverage',
file,
'platform-src',
'Testing Matrix requires coverage for platform/device-response changes',
),
);
}
return selections;
};
function isNodeIntegrationPath(file: string): boolean {
return (
file.startsWith('test/integration/') &&
!file.slice('test/integration/'.length).includes('/') &&
file.endsWith('.ts')
);
}
const vitestRelatedOwnership: OwnershipRule = ({ file, isTs, underSrc, underTest }) =>
isTs && (underSrc || underTest) && !isNodeIntegrationPath(file)
? [
reason(
'vitest-related',
file,
'vitest:related',
'Vitest resolves affected tests through its static module graph',
),
]
: [];
// Workspace package source (#1490 W0): bundled into the published artifact,
// type-checked in the root graph, covered by Vitest's module graph, and
// guarded by layering R11. Fallow scans it too — the W0 ignorePatterns entry
// claimed its resolver could not follow workspace specifiers, which stopped
// being true (it resolves @agent-device/* through each exports map), so an
// extraction into packages/ no longer takes its own dead code out of scope.
const workspacePackageOwnership: OwnershipRule = ({ file, isTs }) => {
if (!isTs || !/^packages\/[^/]+\/src\//.test(file)) return [];
const selections = [
reason('format', file, 'gate:format', 'oxfmt covers packages/'),
reason('lint', file, 'gate:lint', 'oxlint covers packages/'),
reason('typecheck', file, 'gate:typecheck', 'tsc includes packages/'),
reason('fallow', file, 'gate:fallow', 'fallow audits changed TypeScript for dead code'),
reason('layering', file, 'package-src', 'layering R11 guards workspace package boundaries'),
reason(
'vitest-related',
file,
'vitest:related',
'Vitest resolves affected tests through its static module graph',
),
];
if (!isTestPath(file)) {
selections.push(
reason('build', file, 'package-src', 'package source is bundled into the published artifact'),
);
}
return selections;
};
const nodeIntegrationOwnership: OwnershipRule = ({ file }) =>
isNodeIntegrationPath(file)
? [reason('integration-node', file, 'node-integration', 'node --test integration smoke')]
: [];
const testAppOwnership: OwnershipRule = ({ file }) => {
if (!file.startsWith('examples/test-app/')) return [];
if (!/\.(?:[cm]?[jt]sx?|json)$/.test(file)) return [];
return [
reason('format', file, 'gate:format', 'oxfmt covers the Expo test app'),
reason('lint', file, 'gate:lint', 'oxlint covers the Expo test app'),
reason(
'test-app-typecheck',
file,
'own:test-app',
'the Expo test app has an isolated TypeScript dependency graph',
),
];
};
// The frozen replay-compat corpus (#1417). `.ad` fixture data would otherwise
// fail open on its extension: its only consumer is the unit-lane corpus test.
// Any corpus change — script or manifest — also runs the history-backed
// provenance verifier, which is the only gate that can prove an entry's blob
// really came from the release tag it names.
const replayCompatOwnership: OwnershipRule = ({ file }) => {
if (!file.startsWith('test/replay-compat/')) return [];
const selections = [
reason(
'replay-compat',
file,
'own:replay-compat-provenance',
'corpus provenance is re-derived from released git blobs',
),
];
if (file.endsWith('.ad')) {
selections.push(
reason(
'unit',
file,
'own:replay-compat',
'frozen replay-compat corpus is asserted by the unit-lane corpus test',
),
);
}
return selections;
};
const BUILD_OWNERSHIP: ReadonlyArray<{
check: CheckId;
rule: string;
detail: string;
owns: (file: string) => boolean;
}> = [
{
check: 'swift-runner',
rule: 'own:swift',
detail: 'Swift runner sources require the XCUITest build',
owns: (file) => file.startsWith('apple/runner/') || file.endsWith('.swift'),
},
{
check: 'android-helpers',
rule: 'own:android-helpers',
detail: 'Android helper packages have their own build',
owns: (file) =>
file.startsWith('android/snapshot-helper/') || file.startsWith('android/ime-helper/'),
},
{
check: 'macos-helper',
rule: 'own:macos-helper',
detail: 'macOS helper is a separate Swift package build',
owns: (file) => file.startsWith('apple/macos-helper/'),
},
{
check: 'mcp-metadata',
rule: 'own:mcp',
detail: 'MCP registry metadata must stay in sync',
owns: (file) => file === 'server.json' || file === 'smithery.yaml',
},
];
const buildOwnership: OwnershipRule = ({ file }, input) => {
const selections = BUILD_OWNERSHIP.filter((entry) => entry.owns(file)).map((entry) =>
reason(entry.check, file, entry.rule, entry.detail),
);
if ((input.packageEntryFiles ?? []).includes(file)) {
selections.push(
reason('build', file, 'own:public-surface', 'public package entry affects declarations'),
reason(
'package',
file,
'own:public-surface',
'a public entry must still resolve from a clean install',
),
);
}
return selections;
};
const OWNERSHIP_RULES: readonly OwnershipRule[] = [
formatGate,
staticTsGates,
srcProdGate,
vitestRelatedOwnership,
workspacePackageOwnership,
nodeIntegrationOwnership,
testAppOwnership,
replayCompatOwnership,
buildOwnership,
];
function fileFacts(file: string): FileFacts {
const isTs = file.endsWith('.ts') && !file.endsWith('.d.ts');
const underSrc = file.startsWith('src/');
return {
file,
isTs,
underSrc,
underTest: file.startsWith('test/'),
isSrcProd: underSrc && isTs && !isTestPath(file),
};
}
function failOpenFor(file: string): FailOpenReason | null {
if (isSelectorOwning(file)) {
return {
path: file,
rule: 'selector-owning',
detail: 'change to the affected-check selector cannot be trusted to select itself',
};
}
if (isWorkflowTooling(file)) {
return {
path: file,
rule: 'workflow-tooling',
detail: 'workflow/tooling change can alter any gate',
};
}
return null;
}
// --- Selection --------------------------------------------------------------
export function selectChecks(input: SelectInput): CheckPlan {
const reasons: SelectionReason[] = [];
const failOpenReasons: FailOpenReason[] = [];
const docsOnlyPaths: string[] = [];
for (const file of input.changedFiles) {
const failOpen = failOpenFor(file);
if (failOpen) {
failOpenReasons.push(failOpen);
continue;
}
if (isDocs(file)) {
docsOnlyPaths.push(file);
continue;
}
const facts = fileFacts(file);
const selections = OWNERSHIP_RULES.flatMap((rule) => rule(facts, input));
if (selections.length === 0) {
failOpenReasons.push({
path: file,
rule: 'unknown-path',
detail: 'path has no derivable owner; run the full set to stay safe',
});
continue;
}
// `format` is an always-on gate, not evidence of test/build ownership. A
// file we can only route to formatting (e.g. a non-.ts fixture under
// test/) has no derivable suite owner, so treat it as ambiguous and fail
// open rather than silently narrowing to just `format`.
if (!selections.some((selection) => selection.check !== 'format')) {
failOpenReasons.push({
path: file,
rule: 'ambiguous-path',
detail: 'only formatting is derivable; no test/build owner, so run the full set',
});
continue;
}
reasons.push(...selections);
}
if (failOpenReasons.length > 0) {
return { failOpen: true, checks: [...ALL_CHECKS], reasons, failOpenReasons, docsOnlyPaths };
}
const selected = new Set(reasons.map((entry) => entry.check));
return {
failOpen: false,
checks: ALL_CHECKS.filter((check) => selected.has(check)),
reasons,
failOpenReasons,
docsOnlyPaths,
};
}