2 Commits

Author	SHA1	Message	Date
Michał Pierzchała	ccf64f6797	ci: move parked device replay suites to a dispatch-only workflow (#1781 A1) (#1794) ... * ci: move parked device replay suites to a dispatch-only workflow (#1781 A1) Both full-tier device jobs have failed every scheduled run since 2026-07-24: the Android suite inside full-tier scenarios that had never executed end to end, the iOS suite on varying steps. They move to .github/workflows/replays-manual.yml, which has no `schedule:`, so the schedule stops emitting a guaranteed failure while the suites stay runnable on demand. A job-level `if: github.event_name == 'workflow_dispatch'` would have looked the same and lied: `workflowLanes()` decides `qualifying` per workflow FILE and never reads job-level `if:`, so the manifest kept reporting replay-android, replay-ios, and replay-ios-device as scheduled-lane owners — the silent-owner-loss failure the manifest exists to catch. A separate file is what the file-level model already reads correctly. Those three checks now have no pull_request/schedule owner, so they are declared as MANUAL_ONLY_OWNERS rather than folded into UNPROVABLE_OWNERS, whose claim ("it runs, this loader cannot see it") is no longer true for replay-android. check:gate-manifest drops from 48 to 46 wired checks and names the three on every run. Two tests pin it: a dispatch-only lane is non-qualifying however many gates it declares, and every manual-only declaration must name a registered check that no qualifying lane owns, so a re-scheduled lane cannot keep a stale exemption. * ci: attest manual-only checks against their dispatch lane (#1781 A1) Review P1: MANUAL_ONLY_OWNERS was a negative allowlist — it proved each entry named a registered check no qualifying lane owned, but nothing tied the entry to a lane that can still run it. Deleting a parked job, or its run-gate step, would have left the manifest green and still printing the check as manual-only: parked coverage silently becoming deleted coverage. Each entry now names its dispatch lane, and a new 'manual-only' audit assertion resolves that name against the derived model: the lane must exist, must still be dispatch-only, and must still declare the gate. replay-android carries an explicit `opaque` flag because its gate sits inside the third-party emulator action's `script:` (#1429), so the job's existence is the whole attestation the model can make — and the flag says so rather than letting an unreadable lane look like a declaring one. Four regressions pin both directions: deleting a declaration reports the check as unowned; deleting the parked job fails with 'no workflow defines'; re-scheduling the lane fails until the entry is dropped; and a parked lane that loses its run-gate step fails unless the entry is opaque. * ci: make manual-only mean dispatch-only, not merely non-qualifying (#1781 A1) Review follow-up: the attestation checked `qualifying === false`, which is true of any lane that is not pull_request/schedule. Swapping `workflow_dispatch` for `push` in replays-manual.yml would have kept the audit green and the checks printed as manual-only, while the runs nobody starts by hand quietly started themselves on every push. The lane model now keeps the trigger names instead of collapsing them into that one bit, and the manual-only assertion requires `workflow_dispatch` and nothing else. Three planted regressions cover the gap the review named: a parked lane re-triggered by `push` fails, a parked lane with no trigger at all fails, and the loader test pins that trigger kinds survive into the model (a push lane reads `[push]`, the nightly reads `[schedule, workflow_dispatch]`).	2026-08-18 09:59:34 +02:00
Michał Pierzchała	9c22467832	refactor(ci): make gate ownership structural (#1429) (#1753) ... * test(ci): prove every registered gate is owned and reachable (#1429) A check that silently stops running looks exactly like a green build. Two suites had already stopped: `check:tmpdir-leaks` (with its model tests) and `test:fixture-cache` are real package scripts that no workflow ran, reachable only through the `check:unit` aggregate CI never invokes. `CHECK_CATALOG` becomes the registry of every check and `pnpm gate <id>` the only way CI runs one, so finding what a lane runs is a scan for `pnpm gate` rather than an attempt to interpret shell. `pnpm check:gate-manifest` then asserts against the real workflows that every registered check is run by some qualifying lane (per unit, not per script name), that every check the real selector activates for a path is run by a lane that path would start (#1420's class), and that every Vitest project and suite script belongs to a check. The wiring that keeps those honest is asserted too: a gate id must name a registered check, an `if:` must be ruled on in GATE_CONDITIONS so `if: false` unowns what it guards, an action declared to run a gate is proven to, and a job whose steps the loader cannot open fails closed. It deliberately does not try to prove CI runs project code only through `pnpm gate`. Whether a shell block executes project code is not decidable from its text, so shell this model does not recognise earns no ownership credit — the failure direction is a check reported unowned, never one waved through. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com> Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01SkS4S8XXrfkJ8TD1VBKkvJ * test(ci): update the two suites that assert on rewired workflow text `scripts/mutation/workflow.test.ts` and `test/ci/trusted-fixture-artifact.test.mjs` read the workflow and action files and assert on their command text, so routing those steps through `pnpm gate <id>` moved what they were matching. They are the two suites the manifest cannot help with: it proves a gate is still run, not that a test asserting on how CI spells a command was updated with it. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com> Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01SkS4S8XXrfkJ8TD1VBKkvJ * fix(ci): credit gates by execution shape, and keep every guard Three ways the manifest could report a gate as owned when it does not run. 1. Crediting was a substring scan over `run:`, which #1429 explicitly rules out — "do not infer reachability from a command name merely appearing in workflow text". `false && pnpm gate x`, a gate inside `if false; then … fi`, one named in a heredoc, and `echo pnpm gate x` all credited it. There is a live instance: conformance-regenerate.yml's "Fail if regeneration changed anything" step names `pnpm gate maestro-regenerate` inside an error message telling a human to run it, and that credited the gate. A gate now counts only as the first command segment of a line, and a body carrying shell structure earns nothing. Reachability inside a script is not decidable, so this does not try: unrecognised shape means no credit and the check reports unowned. `VAR=$(pnpm gate x …)` is read, since the assignment form is unambiguous and the gate runs. 2. Job-level `if:` was not modelled at all, though six live jobs carry one, so a job that cannot run still credited every gate inside it. Two conditions on the mutation lanes are now declared. 3. A caller's `if:` REPLACED the guard on a nested composite-action step (`guard[0] ?? step.condition`), so an outer `always()` erased an inner `if: false`. Steps carry every guard between the lane and the step. Also corrects two source comments that still claimed project code run outside the runner fails the manifest. It does not: such a step earns no credit. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com> Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01SkS4S8XXrfkJ8TD1VBKkvJ * ci: add the run-gate action that names a gate structurally The seam the ownership proof will read instead of shell. A lane says which gate it runs in `with.gate`, a typed input the manifest reads straight out of the YAML and validates against CHECK_CATALOG. Nothing here is wired yet — the ~60 call sites and the model change follow. Added first so the target of that conversion is reviewable on its own. `args` cannot select which gate runs; it is appended after the id, so the worst a wrong value does is fail the gate it already named. There is no `|| true` and no output capture: the gate's exit code is the step's exit code, so a gate cannot run without being able to fail its lane. Part of #1429. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com> Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01SkS4S8XXrfkJ8TD1VBKkvJ * merge: main (#1770) and route its three new steps through the runner #1770 landed the orphan-check fix on main, wiring `check:tmpdir-leaks`, `check:tmpdir-leaks:test` and `test:fixture-cache` into Coverage, Layering Guard and Integration Tests. This branch had wired the same three through `pnpm gate`, so the merge produced two steps per check rather than a conflict — each check ran twice. Kept main's steps, with the placement and reasoning reviewed on #1770, and changed only their `run:` line to the canonical runner. Dropped this branch's duplicates. Net effect on CI is unchanged: the same three checks, in the same three lanes, once each. Gate manifest green after the merge: 47 checks wired across 33 lanes. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com> Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01SkS4S8XXrfkJ8TD1VBKkvJ * fix(ci): address review — suite detection, freerange, glob, vacuous skip-list Six review findings plus the mutation blocker. [bug] `registered` was shape-only, so a `test:*` script running `node src/bin.ts test <dir>` resolved to a `script:` leaf and was invisible. Four `test:replay:*` scripts were owned only because someone hand-registered them; `test:replay:android` was neither registered nor reported while the nightly ran the same six .ad files by inlining them. A `test:*` script is now a suite by name. `replay-android` is registered, and the nightly runs the script instead of re-listing its files so the two cannot drift. The nightly invokes it inside `reactivecircus/android-emulator-runner`'s `script:` input — shell handed to a third-party action this loader does not read — so the suite executes but cannot be credited. Recorded in UNPROVABLE_OWNERS with that exact reason rather than assumed. The fixed detector also found a second orphan the review did not name: `test:integration:progress`. That one is a reporter whose `--check` sibling is the registered gate, so it is declared in REPORTING_SCRIPTS — a declaration that itself fails when inert. [bug] `freerange` defaulted to localRunnable, so fail-open ran `fr` (a Bun binary) on the pre-push path. Now false. [suggestion] The `--run` skip-list asserted `build:android-snapshot-helper`, a name `android-helpers` no longer uses, so it could not fail. Derived from the catalog instead. [suggestion] `matchesGlob` joined `**` splits with `.*`, making the adjacent slash mandatory — GitHub's `**` matches zero directories, so `src/**/*.test.ts` did not match `src/a.test.ts`. Pinned against `packages/*/src/**/*.test.ts`. [suggestion] Deleted the unwired `run-gate` action. It had no callers, was absent from GATE_ACTIONS, and its comment described a system that had not shipped. It returns with the rewiring, not before. [suggestion] Collapsed the module headers that narrated discarded designs. Mutation: `daemon entrypoint publishes HTTP metadata and cleans up on shutdown` is the only test here that spawns a real daemon process. It takes ~1.1s alone but exceeds Vitest's 5s default inside Stryker's dry run, which aborts the sweep before a single mutant runs. Given 30s. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com> Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01SkS4S8XXrfkJ8TD1VBKkvJ * fix(mutation): order sandbox aliases longest-first so subpaths resolve Every shard of the mutation sweep aborted in Stryker's dry run with: Cannot find package '@agent-device/selectors/engine' imported from .tmp/stryker/sandbox-*/src/core/selector-pipeline.ts The alias was generated correctly; it just never won. Vite matches a STRING alias by prefix and takes the first hit, and `workspaceSpecifierTargets` emitted the bare `@agent-device/selectors` ahead of the subpath entries. The bare entry therefore captured `@agent-device/selectors/engine` and rewrote it to `…/src/index.ts/engine`, which does not exist; Node fell back to real package resolution, could not find the subpath inside the sandbox, and the dry run failed before a single mutant ran — so the shard uploaded an empty envelope instead of a report and the ratchet failed for want of one. Sorting longest specifier first makes the most specific alias win: @agent-device/selectors/engine -> packages/selectors/src/engine.ts @agent-device/selectors/ast -> packages/selectors/src/ast.ts @agent-device/selectors -> packages/selectors/src/index.ts `/ast` never tripped this because nothing in a related test set imported it; `selector-pipeline.ts` introduced the first subpath import that mattered (#1744), so the mutation lane has been unable to run since that landed. Any PR touching `scripts/mutation/**` — which fails open into the full sweep — would have hit it. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com> Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01SkS4S8XXrfkJ8TD1VBKkvJ * refactor: derive gate ownership from workflow structure * fix: run gates without optional arguments * fix: resolve mutation workspace subpaths exactly --------- Co-authored-by: Claude <noreply@anthropic.com>	2026-08-12 16:02:18 +02:00